Every Thanksgiving table has a side dish that disappears first, and in six states, the bowl that empties fastest is probably the mashed potatoes. That is the finding in Campbell’s newest survey of holiday sides, which maps a favorite for every state.
Mashed potatoes are the favorite Thanksgiving side in California, Indiana, Iowa, Kansas, Nebraska and West Virginia, according to Campbell’s 2026 State of the Sides report. Utah is tied for first between mashed potatoes and stuffing. Stuffing, also called dressing, still leads the country overall.

The six mashed potato states
The Campbell’s report says mashed potatoes are “quietly building an empire.” California, Nebraska, Utah and West Virginia joined the mashed potato fan club this year, alongside longtime loyalists Indiana, Iowa and Kansas. Mental Floss, in a Nov. 11, 2026 piece by Jenny Cohen, counted six outright winners and noted that Utah is tied for first.
The result stands out because Idaho, the largest potato producer in the country, did not pick mashed potatoes. Mental Floss reported that Idaho chose stuffing as its first choice instead.
Stuffing still leads nationally
Stuffing and dressing hold the top spot overall. Campbell’s says stuffing is the number one side in 39 states, while Mental Floss counted 38 states with a clear win and a 39th, Utah, in a tie. NBC Chicago, in a Nov. 19, 2026 story by Maria Chamberlain, reported that the top five sides are stuffing and dressing, mashed potatoes, yams and sweet potatoes, mac and cheese, and green bean casserole. Mashed potatoes ranked second, the same order as in each of the past three years, according to Mental Floss.
Anyone who wonders why holiday menus feel so fixed can browse strange Thanksgiving traditions that everyone pretends are not weird and odd American traditions that confuse the rest of the world, which cover how many of these habits are shared. For a nostalgic angle, foods from the 1960s that boomers loved shows how long some comfort dishes have lasted. Family friction over the menu is common, and six things families quietly argue about at Thanksgiving dinner includes the dishes themselves. Hosts planning around favorites can also run through seven kitchen checks before Thanksgiving dinner on Nov. 26.
Where mac and cheese and sweet potatoes win
Campbell’s says mac and cheese is now the favorite in four states: New York, North Carolina, Georgia and Texas. Georgia takes it furthest, with 79% of Georgians serving it, the highest share anywhere in the country, according to the report. Mental Floss said New York is the only state to rank it first two years in a row.
Louisiana marches to its own beat, in the report’s words, naming sweet potatoes or yams the winning side. Mental Floss added that Louisiana is the only state to pick sweet potatoes, which can be baked as a casserole with melted mini marshmallows or candied with sugar and spices.

How many sides end up on the table
NBC Chicago reported that 86% of Americans serve at least four sides at Thanksgiving, with the average meal featuring five, for an estimated 749 million side dishes across the country. The report also found that four in five Americans enjoy cooking the sides more than the turkey, and that 46% would be happy with a Thanksgiving meal made up entirely of sides.
Regional habits vary. In the Midwest, green bean casserole appears on 60% of tables, according to Campbell’s, with Nebraska at 70% and Missouri at 68%. Colorado and Maryland are keeping things minimal, with averages of 4.9 and 5.1 sides, letting the turkey take the spotlight.
The ranking has a practical side for shoppers. A side that tops a state’s list tends to be the one hosts cook in the largest quantity, which is why a bowl of mashed potatoes often needs the biggest serving spoon on the table. Anyone shopping for the meal should expect prices and package sizes to vary by store and region, and a recipe that serves a crowd in one household may only be a starting point in another.
The survey also highlights how the plate itself has changed. Stuffing, mashed potatoes, sweet potatoes, mac and cheese and green bean casserole have all held spots in the national top five across the report’s five-year look, with only the order shifting, according to Campbell’s. That steadiness suggests the debate is less about which dishes belong on the table and more about which one gets the first scoop.
How the survey was done
The numbers deserve some caution. Campbell’s says it commissioned a survey of 5,017 U.S. adults who celebrate Thanksgiving, with 100 Americans in each of the 50 states, conducted in August and September 2026 by the independent research organization Reputation Leaders. The margin of error is plus or minus 1.4% for national results and plus or minus 9.8% for state results, at 95% confidence.
That wide state-level margin means a close race, such as stuffing versus mashed potatoes in Utah, can go either way. A state’s favorite reflects a sample of 100 residents, not a count of every table. Campbell’s, as a soup and sides brand, also has a business interest in the topic.
A short history of the favorites
Both leading sides are old. According to Wikipedia’s mashed potato entry, an early recipe appears in Hannah Glasse’s The Art of Cookery, published in 1747, which mashed potatoes in a saucepan with milk, salt and butter. Wikipedia’s stuffing entry says the earliest documentary evidence is a Roman cookbook, Apicius’ De Re Coquinaria, and that poultry stuffing often combines breadcrumbs, onion, celery, spices and herbs such as sage.
For hosts, the state map offers a quick planning tip: if the guest list leans toward a state where mashed potatoes lead, a bigger bowl may be wise. Preferences differ by household, and the survey describes averages, not rules.
This article was produced with AI assistance and edited for accuracy against the sources linked above.
Image: Dorevabelfiore – CC BY-SA 4.0/Wikimedia Commons