12 Zodiac Signs and the Christmas Cookie Astrologer Theresa Reed Picked for Each in The Old Farmer’s Almanac

A plate of cookies goes around the room, and someone always reaches for the same kind every year. Astrologers like to say that habit says something about a sign, and one of them put the idea on paper for the holiday baking season.

Astrologer Theresa Reed matched 12 zodiac signs with 12 Christmas cookies in a piece for The Old Farmer’s Almanac dated September 24, 2026. The Almanac, founded in 1792 by Robert Bailey Thomas, published the list in its holiday cookie feature. Here is each pairing in her words, paraphrased, with a little cookie history added. Her list follows the calendar of signs, from Aries in March through Pisces in February, and every cookie below comes straight from that Almanac feature.

A plate of assorted Christmas cookies
Fagles – CC BY-SA 2.5/Wikimedia Commons

Aries: Cranberry Cardamom and Citrus Pinwheels

In the Almanac feature, which comes from a publication first issued in 1793, Reed describes Aries as a sign that wants bold flavor and a break from tradition, with a spicy edge that sets the cookie apart on a crowded plate. The pinwheels are festive with a twist and a little spice, a fit for anyone who skips the plain sugar cookie. Cranberry, cardamom and citrus together make a brighter, sharper plate than most holiday trays offer.

Taurus: Turtle Thumbprints

Taurus is tied to comfort and indulgence. A thumbprint cookie is a molded shortbread-style cookie with a filling, and the turtle version stays traditional but rich. Raspberry jam is the classic filling for the Swedish version known as hallongrotta, or raspberry cave.

Gemini: Old-Fashioned Gingerbread People

Gemini is called social and restless when alone, so gingerbread people keep company even on a snowed-in day. A crowded table brings out the chatty side, and families quietly argue about plenty at holiday dinners, so a cookie shaped like a person gives everyone something to laugh about. The gingerbread figure is first attributed to the court of England’s first Queen Elizabeth, who reportedly served them to foreign dignitaries.

Cancer: Mother’s Forgotten Mint Cookies

Cancer is the nurturer of the zodiac, tied to home and family, and the cookie carries a name that sounds like a family recipe card. These cookies are meringues, light and old-school, the kind a grandmother might have kept in a tin, back when 7 things were in nearly every 1980s kitchen and the cookie jar sat beside them.

Leo: Lemon-Coconut Cookies

Leo is ruled by the Sun and loves the spotlight, the kind of guest who follows simple houseguest etiquette and still stands out, and Reed notes that winter can dampen the mood. Lemon and coconut are meant to recall summer on a cold December afternoon.

Virgo: Swedish Spritz Cookies

Virgo is described as a perfectionist who appreciates order, and spritz cookies come out uniform, with colored sugar adding a creative touch, much like the easy-to-use gadgets that simplify everyday life at home. The name comes from the German verb for squeezing dough through a press, as the Wikipedia page on spritz cookies explains.

Libra: Pistachio-Cranberry Icebox Cookies

Libra wants things that are beautiful, delicious and elegant. These icebox cookies are striking to look at and suited to a sophisticated palate. Icebox cookies chill as a log in the refrigerator before slicing, so they can be made ahead for a busy week of holiday guests, when a single-cup or full-pot brewer runs nonstop. The green and red slices suit a holiday platter, and the cookies look as good as they taste.

Scorpio: Caramel Candy Cookies

Scorpio is secretive and drawn to mystery. The cookies look plain on the outside but hide a rich caramel swirl and a gooey center, a surprise that suits the sign. Reed pairs mystery with flavor, and the swirl stays hidden until the first bite. Anyone who bites in expecting a plain cookie gets a small shock of sweetness.

Gingerbread cookies on a table
GutMaze – CC BY-SA 4.0/Wikimedia Commons

Sagittarius: Winter Energy Cookies

Sagittarius, the sign that begins on November 22, is always on the move, whether hitting the slopes or traveling, and a thermos and a tin of cookies are an easy pair. Reed names this one as the cookie to pack along for a sign that rarely sits still.

Capricorn: Classic Christmas Sugar Cookies

Capricorn has refined taste, with clean lines and simple shapes. The classic sugar cookie balances tradition with quiet luxury, and it pairs well with a pot of coffee for holiday guests.

Aquarius: Snowball Cookies

Aquarius, with birthdays from January 20 to February 18, is the most cool-headed sign, possibly because of its birth in the coldest part of the year. Snowballs are a playful winter sweet, suggested with hot cocoa. The same cookie goes by Russian tea cake, Mexican wedding cookie and butterball, according to the Wikipedia entry on Russian tea cakes.

Pisces: Candy Cane Dessert Squares

Pisces is gentle, sensitive and kind. The creamy, peppermint-flavored bars are a sweet, mellow match for the sign. Peppermint and cream make an easy dessert for a crowd, cut into squares instead of rolled and baked one tray at a time.

The Almanac piece ends by asking readers which cookie suits them best and whether they agree, so the list is open to debate. Astrology is for fun, and no cookie has to match a birthday. Plenty of households bake the same recipe every December whatever the sign on the calendar.

This article was produced with AI assistance and edited for accuracy against the sources linked above.

Image: L293D – CC BY-SA 4.0/Wikimedia Commons

Author

More Posts You May love

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *