The pantry shelf looks great when it is lined with jars, and a tray of freshly sealed salsa is a proud moment for any home canner. It is also the moment when a shortcut can do the most damage, because a jar that looks perfect can still have been processed wrong.
University extension offices have published lists of canning mistakes, and several of them overlap on the same never-dos: no ovens or dishwashers, no pumpkin purée, no butter and no extra onions in salsa. Here is what each source says, with the dates where the pages give them.

No Ovens, Open Kettles or Dishwashers
Mississippi State University Extension’s 10 home canning mistakes to avoid, written by Susan Collins-Smith and based on a Utah State University Extension list, says processing in an oven, an open kettle or a dishwasher does not generate enough heat. The page does not carry a publication date. It points home canners to a water bath instead. Home canners who garden may like this guide to elevated garden beds for fall greens and herbs, and a list of kitchen checks before Thanksgiving dinner is a handy companion.
Michigan State University Extension agrees. In a Sept. 7, 2017, article by Michelle Jarvie, the office says canning in ovens, microwaves, dishwashers or compost piles is not considered safe, and names the accepted methods: boiling water bath, pressure canning and steam canning. High-acid foods such as most fruits suit a water bath or steam canner, while low-acid foods such as vegetables and meats need pressure canning. A kitchen with a busy stove can use this list of things to know about keeping a fire extinguisher near the kitchen.
No Extra Onions in Salsa
Salsa is where creativity gets tricky. Mississippi State says extra onions, chilies or other vegetables lower the acidity of the mix, which makes the jar unsafe. The University of Nebraska-Lincoln’s common canning issues page, written by Nancy Frecks in 2022, says to use only researched salsa recipes. It adds that peppers can be swapped if the total amount stays the same, and that extra lemon juice or vinegar can be added for tartness.
The same Nebraska page covers tomatoes: add 2 tablespoons of bottled lemon juice or 1/2 teaspoon of citric acid per quart, or 1 tablespoon or 1/4 teaspoon per pint, because not every tomato is acidic enough on its own.
No Pumpkin Purée
Just after a pumpkin-heavy holiday, this one matters. The Nebraska page says mashed or puréed pumpkin and winter squash are not safe to can, and that they should be frozen instead. It says USDA guidance exists only for pumpkin or winter squash cut into 1-inch cubes.
The same page says summer squash and zucchini are not considered safe to can because the pressure-canning time has not been established, and suggests freezing or pickling them. Elderberries are too low in acid for standard home canning, and the page says to freeze them.
No Butter, Herb Oils or Jarred Bread
Nebraska’s list also rules out butter, which is low in acid, and herb-and-oil mixtures. It says quick breads baked in jars and sealed with lids are unsafe, and that there are no tested processes for re-canning commercially processed food. For shelving ideas after a harvest, a guide to seasonal storage and these storage hacks may help.
No Skipping Venting, Gauges or Cooling Steps
Mississippi State lists several habits that apply to pressure canners. Skipping the venting step traps air and creates cold spots where food does not reach the needed temperature. A dial gauge that is not tested every year can read wrong, leading to under-processed jars. Cooling a pressure canner under running water is another never-do, because the residual heat is counted in the processing time. Letting hot-packed food cool in the jars before processing is also on the list, and the page calls it a particular concern for salsa, vegetables and canned meat.
Altitude matters too: at higher elevations the pressure or time must be increased, or the food may be under-processed.
No Family Recipes, Starch or Reused Jars
Mississippi State says to skip homemade recipes and to avoid adding extra starch, flour or thickener, because thicker food heats more slowly. Nebraska agrees on thickeners, saying they are acceptable only in tested recipes in the specified amounts. Michigan State says family recipes may be out of date, and that recipes should come from reputable sources published within the last 5 to 6 years.
On equipment, Michigan State says reusing store-bought spaghetti sauce jars is unsafe because they are designed for one use, and that pressure cookers are not substitutes for pressure canners. Michigan State also warns against produce picked up from the ground, overripe fruit and vegetables with blemishes or soft spots. The National Center for Home Food Preservation’s canning guide describes canning as heating food in sealed jars so that a vacuum seal forms as the jar cools, and its site carries a post labeling dry canning of raw vegetables an unsafe practice.
A cook who wants to try a new jar of anything this season can start with a tested recipe and check the date on it.
The pattern across the three extension pages is consistent: tested recipes, the right method for the food’s acidity and no improvised swaps. Because the Michigan State article dates to 2017 and the Mississippi State page carries no date, a canner who wants current instructions can check them against the newest recipe from the National Center for Home Food Preservation before the next batch.
This article was produced with AI assistance and edited for accuracy against the sources linked above.
Image: Nutrition, Food Safety and Health – CC0/Wikimedia Commons