Six Chesapeake Region Thanksgiving Traditions: Delaware Dilly Crab Dip, Maryland Oyster Stuffing, Virginia Glazed Ham, West Virginia Squash Casserole

On Thanksgiving, a cold dip often goes out while the turkey is still in the oven, and in one corner of the country that dip is made with crab. The Chesapeake Bay watershed spans six states, and each has its own way of filling the holiday table.

The Chesapeake Bay Program, the regional partnership that works on the bay, put together a list of six Thanksgiving food traditions from across those states: Delaware dilly crab dip, Maryland oyster stuffing, New York apple pie, Pennsylvania shoofly pie, Virginia glazed ham and West Virginia squash casserole. Here is what makes each one regional, along with a few extra Maryland dishes from other sources.

A honey-glazed ham on a wooden cutting board
Rerun van Pelt – CC BY-SA 2.0/Wikimedia Commons

Delaware Dilly Crab Dip

According to the Chesapeake Bay Program, Delaware’s pick is a cold dip of flaked crab, mayonnaise, sour cream and dried dill. It is described as an easy appetizer that can be served while the turkey cooks, which makes it a handy starter for a host whose oven is already full. A comparison of ways to free up the oven this Thanksgiving shows how some cooks add counter-top appliances for the sides.

Crab is a fitting choice for the region. Wikipedia’s Chesapeake Bay entry says the bay is well known for blue crabs, clams and oysters, and that its drainage basin covers parts of New York, Pennsylvania, Delaware, Maryland, Virginia and West Virginia, plus all of Washington, D.C.

Maryland Oyster Stuffing

Maryland’s entry is stuffing made with local oysters and their liquid, mixed with chopped vegetables and crusty bread, for a rich, salty flavor. Preservation Maryland, in a November 2022 piece on a traditional Maryland Thanksgiving, says the Chesapeake region once produced almost half the world’s oyster supply, which helps explain why oysters ended up in the bread.

The same page adds three more Maryland dishes: Eastern Shore white potato pie, a custard-style pie of mashed white potatoes, cream, eggs, sugar and spices; hoecake, a thin fried cornmeal cake; and wassail, a spiced hot apple cider. Food Network’s state-by-state Thanksgiving list names sweet potato pie for Maryland, so the state’s table can carry more than one kind of pie. For a cook juggling a long cooking weekend, a post on holiday pace and everyday habits offers ideas for keeping the season manageable, and a single cup or full pot comparison may help with coffee for early arrivals.

New York Apple Pie

New York is on the bay’s list because its watershed reaches into the state, and the Chesapeake Bay Program points to New York’s crisp, tart apples and its standing as one of the top apple-producing states. Apple pie is the holiday dessert it chose for the region.

Hosts who plan a full dessert table can check the 2026 Thanksgiving dinner cost by state before filling the grocery cart, and a list of kitchen checks before Thanksgiving dinner on Nov. 26 is worth a look before the baking begins. Families traveling to a relative’s table can plan the trip with carry-on suitcases worth packing for Thanksgiving.

A small slice of molasses shoofly pie on a plate
WhatamIdoing – CC BY-SA 4.0/Wikimedia Commons

Pennsylvania Shoofly Pie

Pennsylvania’s pick is the Pennsylvania Dutch molasses dessert. The Chesapeake Bay Program says the brown sugar topping sinks into the molasses base as it bakes, forming a cake-like middle layer, and notes a folk tale that the name came from bakers shooing flies away from the sticky filling.

Wikipedia’s shoofly pie entry gives a different account: the name likely comes from a Philadelphia molasses brand, the fly story is considered apocryphal, and the pie likely began in the 1870s and 1880s as a crustless molasses cake. The entry adds that traditional versions have no eggs, that a wet-bottom version has a stickier, custard-like base, and that a dry-bottom version is cake-like throughout and suits dunking in coffee. It was traditionally a breakfast food eaten with hot coffee rather than a dessert, a detail that surprises many modern cooks.

Virginia Glazed Ham

In Virginia, the Chesapeake Bay Program says, a glazed ham often takes the place of turkey as the main course. Glazes named include honey, brown sugar or Coca-Cola. A ham as the centerpiece changes the shopping list and the oven plan, since the bird is no longer the only thing to roast.

West Virginia Squash Casserole

West Virginia rounds out the list with a creamy, cheesy casserole of squash, onion and cheese, topped with breadcrumbs and baked until bubbly. The Chesapeake Bay Program calls it popular across the southern United States as well as in West Virginia.

Why Regional Dishes Keep Their Place

All six dishes share one thing: each draws on something close at hand, whether bay crab, local oysters, New York apples, molasses from Pennsylvania Dutch kitchens, a Virginia ham or squash from a West Virginia kitchen. Thanksgiving falls on Nov. 26 this year, and the regional dish is often the one that stays on the menu even when the turkey recipe changes.

The Chesapeake Bay Program’s list is not a ranking and not an official menu, only a snapshot of what the bay states cook. Cooks who want to add a bay-region plate this year have six places to start, and the extra Maryland dishes from Preservation Maryland give a seventh through tenth for anyone with room on the sideboard.

This article was produced with AI assistance and edited for accuracy against the sources linked above.

Author

More Posts You May love

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *