Two hundred ten dollars buys a cold Thanksgiving carryout bundle at Maggiano’s Little Italy. Ten dollars more, $220, buys the same bundle hot. Either one feeds 4 to 5 people, which works out to roughly $42 to $52.50 a head cold, or $44 to $55 hot, before tax.
The pickup dates and the order rule are on the chain’s own Thanksgiving 2026 page: cold bundles are ready Wednesday, November 25, hot bundles on Thanksgiving Day, Thursday, November 26, and orders must go in 24 hours before the desired pickup time. A FOX 5 New York roundup from November 5 reports the same prices and dates.

What $210 and $220 Buy: The Menu Side
Per FOX 29 Philadelphia’s Thanksgiving meal deals roundup, the bundle covers roasted turkey, stuffing and garlic mashed potatoes, plus two of the restaurant’s Italian-American standbys, spaghetti and meatballs and four-cheese ravioli. That mix is the point: it is a holiday table with a pasta course attached.
The chain’s page does not list a per-dish breakdown, so extras such as pie or wine should be asked about by phone. According to Wikipedia’s entry on the chain, Maggiano’s started in 1991 in Chicago’s River North neighborhood and later became part of Brinker International, which explains why the same family-style format turns up in so many cities.
The pasta is a quiet advantage. Turkey carries the table for the traditionalists, while the ravioli and meatballs give a crowd with mixed tastes something to reach for, and neither dish needs a pot of boiling water on the holiday.
Another recent piece, on products Americans overpay for without noticing, makes a useful point for this bundle: a fixed price for a full spread is easiest to judge by dividing it, not by comparing it with a single dish.
Cold Versus Hot: Which Day, Which Price
The cold bundle at $210 is the earlier option. It is ready Wednesday, November 25, which suits hosts who would rather reheat at home on the holiday and keep the oven free for a few homemade dishes. A recent comparison of air fryer toaster ovens shows what a second small oven can do for that kind of day.
The hot bundle at $220 is ready on Thanksgiving Day itself. It costs $10 more and skips the reheating step, which matters most for hosts who are driving a long way before dinner. In both cases the bundle serves the same 4 to 5 people.
The cold option has one more quiet perk: pickup happens a day early, ahead of the holiday itself. A report on the 81.5 million Thanksgiving travelers AAA expects is a reminder of how busy that week gets.

The 24-Hour Rule and What It Means for the Calendar
Orders must be placed 24 hours before the desired pickup time, according to the chain’s page. Do the math backward: a cold pickup on Wednesday, November 25 means ordering by the same time on Tuesday, November 24, and a hot pickup on Thursday, November 26 means ordering by the same time on Wednesday, November 25. A guide to pre-guest checks for the kitchen and guest bathroom is a smarter use of the saved cooking time than another trip to the store.
The page says to call the nearest Maggiano’s to order, so availability can differ by location. Prices here come from the chain’s page and the Fox reports, and a local restaurant may set its own limits. A list of 26 ways to save money fast helps put a $210 pickup in context against a full grocery run.
Hosts should also ask about timing at pickup. A hot bundle is meant to be served soon after collection, and a long drive can cool it, so the trip home belongs in the plan. Insulated bags or a pre-warmed oven set to a low temperature can hold dishes until guests sit down, and a quick call on Wednesday can confirm the exact pickup window assigned to the order.
Seating math matters as well. Four to five servings is generous for a small table but thin for a family with teenagers or hungry uncles. A household of six may want to cook one extra side at home, such as green beans or rolls, so that the bundle stretches without a second purchase.
The Catch: Leftovers and the Cost Per Plate
A bundle for 4 to 5 guests also means leftovers. USDA’s leftovers and food safety page says cooked food should be refrigerated within 2 hours, leftovers can be kept for 3 to 4 days, and they should be reheated to 165 degrees Fahrenheit. Sauces and gravies should reach a rolling boil.
The pickup price is also not the full cost of a feast. Drinks, a dessert and a second pasta side add up, and a family of 8 would need two bundles, or $420 to $440.
The last number worth keeping is the gap between the two bundles: $10. For a family that would otherwise spend an hour reheating dishes while guests arrive, that is a small price for a table that is ready on time. For a family with a free oven and a relaxed schedule, the cold bundle at $210 is the better buy.
Whichever version wins, the practical steps are the same: pick the pickup day, call the nearest Maggiano’s at least 24 hours ahead, confirm the time, and clear fridge or oven space before the bundle arrives. A written list of those four steps taped near the phone keeps the plan from slipping in the middle of a busy week.
This article was produced with AI assistance and edited for accuracy against the sources linked above.
Image: Tony Webster – CC BY 2.0/Wikimedia Commons