8 Foods That Keep Better Out of the Refrigerator, From Bread and Honey to Whole Tomatoes and Potatoes

Unpacking groceries usually follows one rule: if in doubt, put it in the fridge. The bread goes in to stay fresh, the tomatoes go in so they last, and the honey ends up on the door next to the mustard.

Whirlpool says that habit works against some of the most common foods in the kitchen. Its list of foods that should not be refrigerated runs to 19 items, and 8 of the most familiar keep better out of the refrigerator, from bread and honey to whole tomatoes and potatoes. Here is what the cold does to each one and where it belongs instead.

A pile of ripe red tomatoes
Geems04 – CC BY-SA 4.0/Wikimedia Commons

1. Bread

Bread is the classic fridge mistake. Whirlpool says the refrigerator can make bread stale and recommends keeping it on the counter for the first 24 hours, then freezing it.

King Arthur Baking explains why in its guide to storing yeast bread. Freezing locks in moisture, but chilling without freezing lets liquid in the loaf keep migrating to the surface, where it evaporates, so the bread goes stale quickly. The baking company’s advice for anything longer than a couple of days is to wrap bread in single-day portions and freeze it, then toast or warm slices before serving.

2. Chocolate

A bar of chocolate stashed in the fridge often comes out with a chalky white film. Whirlpool says refrigeration can make chocolate grainy with a dull flavor and recommends a dark, dry place instead.

Wikipedia’s entry on chocolate says unwrapped chocolate stored in the fridge or freezer can absorb enough moisture to cause a whitish discoloration known as bloom, and that ideal storage is about 59 to 63°F with low humidity. The entry adds that bloomed chocolate is still fine to eat and can be melted for baking. A cool pantry shelf does the job, and these clever kitchen tricks for home cooks include more ways to put pantry space to work.

3. Garlic

Whole garlic bulbs do not need the fridge either. Whirlpool says refrigeration can make the bulbs rubbery and suggests a cool, dry place, such as a cellar or a cupboard away from heat sources.

That cupboard should not be the one above the stove or next to the dishwasher, where warmth and steam collect. A separate list of 6 items that shouldn’t be displayed on a kitchen counter has more ideas for where everyday kitchen items belong.

4. Honey

Honey is one of the easiest pantry foods to store, and one of the most often refrigerated by mistake. Whirlpool says honey can turn hard and lumpy in the fridge and is best left at room temperature.

Wikipedia’s entry on honey explains that it gets thick and sluggish as the temperature drops, and that its viscosity climbs more rapidly with further cooling. That is why a jar from the fridge refuses to drizzle. On the counter or in a cupboard, it stays pourable for tea, toast and the morning coffee, the kind of routine covered in this comparison of single-cup and full-pot coffee makers.

Yellow onions and potatoes stored together in a basket
Daniel Paullll – CC BY-SA 4.0/Wikimedia Commons

5. Onions

Whirlpool says moisture in the fridge can make whole onions soft and moldy. It recommends a cool, dry place for whole onions, and specifically one away from potatoes.

That last detail surprises many cooks, since onions and potatoes are often sold together and stored in the same bin. Shoppers who buy onions by the bag may also want to check this list of 9 items not worth buying at the grocery store.

6. Potatoes

Whirlpool says the moisture of the fridge can make potatoes gritty and sweet, and that they are best kept at room temperature in a paper bag.

The sweetness is a known effect of cold. University of Minnesota Extension’s guide to harvesting and storing home garden vegetables says potatoes meant for frying should be kept at 40 to 50°F to avoid cold-induced sweetening, which can cause discoloration in the fryer. The same guide does list cold, moist conditions for long-term storage of garden potatoes, the kind of setup a root cellar provides, so a large fall harvest is a different case. For the everyday bag from the store, with mashed potatoes on the Thanksgiving menu for November 26, Whirlpool’s paper bag at room temperature is the simpler route.

7. Whole Tomatoes

Whirlpool says whole tomatoes should be stored at room temperature to protect their flavor and juiciness. Sliced or cut tomatoes are the exception and should go into a container in the fridge.

Minnesota Extension adds that tomatoes lose color, firmness and flavor if stored below 40°F, which is the very range a home refrigerator is meant to hold. The U.S. Food and Drug Administration’s safe food handling page says to keep the refrigerator at 40°F or below, which suits milk and leftovers but not a whole tomato still developing its flavor.

8. Whole Melons

The last food on the list is the one that takes up the most fridge space. Whirlpool says whole melons should ripen outside the fridge, while sliced melon should be refrigerated.

Leaving a whole cantaloupe or watermelon on the counter frees up a full shelf. Once it is cut, the pieces go into a covered container in the fridge. A longer list of 20 essential items to keep in the refrigerator shows which foods do need that shelf space.

The common thread is simple. Whole, uncut produce and shelf-stable sweets often keep their best texture and flavor at room temperature, while anything sliced, opened or cooked heads into the cold.

This article was produced with AI assistance and edited for accuracy against the sources linked above.

Image: Deerpeter – CC BY-SA 4.0/Wikimedia Commons

Author

More Posts You May love

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *