Anyone who grew up with Saturday trips to the Golden Arches can probably name one menu item they still miss. Maybe it was a bubbling personal pizza in a cardboard box, or an apple pie with a blistered, deep-fried crust that stayed hot for far too long.
McDonald’s has tested and retired hundreds of items over the decades, and the Wikipedia list of McDonald’s products keeps a running record of the ones that disappeared. Here are 5 that are rarely seen anymore, from the McPizza to the fried apple pie, along with the years they came and went.
.jpg?width=1600)
1. The McPizza
Pizza at McDonald’s sounds like a fever dream to younger diners, but it was real. According to the Wikipedia list, McDonald’s test-marketed a 14-inch pizza in Evansville, Indiana, in 1989, and pizza went on to appear in a number of its restaurants.
The problem was speed. The list says it took 11 minutes to cook a pizza, which clashed with a brand built on fast service. Pizza was discontinued in most restaurants by 1999. A handful of franchise locations held on much longer, and the last two, in Ohio and West Virginia, stopped serving pizza in 2017.
For fans, the McPizza belongs in the same memory box as the snacks and dinners of earlier decades, like the foods from the 1960s that boomers loved. It is also a reminder of how differently families once used fast food, as a weekend dinner out rather than a quick stop.
1963: The Hula Burger
Long before plant-based patties, McDonald’s tried a meatless burger built around fruit. The Hula Burger swapped the beef for a slice of grilled pineapple with cheese on a bun. The Wikipedia list says it was test-marketed in 1963 alongside the Filet-O-Fish, aimed at Roman Catholic customers who skipped meat on Fridays during Lent.
The story behind the contest is a fast-food legend. QSR Magazine reports that franchisee Lou Groen developed a fish sandwich in 1962 after noticing his Friday sales falling in a largely Catholic neighborhood. Founder Ray Kroc backed his own pineapple creation, and the two agreed that whichever sandwich sold better on a Friday would win a permanent spot on the menu.
The fish sandwich won easily. According to QSR, Kroc had also bet employee Fred Turner a new suit that the Hula Burger would come out ahead, and he lost. The Filet-O-Fish went on to become a permanent fixture, while the Hula Burger faded into trivia. QSR notes the winning fish sandwich joined the permanent menu at 29 cents, a price that looks almost unreal next to a modern fast-food receipt. Not every price has climbed at the same pace, though, and a roundup of things that are actually getting cheaper offers a few surprises. Kitchens of that era had their own quirks, too, as a look at things nearly every 1960s kitchen had shows.

3. The Fried Apple Pie
Of all the retired items, this one may draw the strongest nostalgia. McDonald’s introduced its pies in 1968, and the Wikipedia list notes that they were exclusively deep-fried until 1992. After that, the chain moved to a baked version in most U.S. restaurants.
Fans of the original still describe the crackly, bubbled crust that only a fryer could produce. The baked pie has a smoother, flakier pastry, and the two are easy to tell apart side by side. For anyone who remembers the fried version, it is part of the same era as the appliances and habits found in nearly every 1980s kitchen across America.
4. Chicken Selects
Chicken Selects were McDonald’s answer to diners who wanted whole strips of chicken breast instead of nuggets. The Wikipedia list says they were introduced in early 1998 and made a permanent return in late October 2003.
The strips were served with dipping sauces and won a following of their own. Even so, McDonald’s stopped selling Chicken Selects in the United States in February 2013, according to the list. Home cooks who miss them often try breading chicken strips themselves, and a list of clever kitchen tricks for home cooks can make that kind of copycat project easier.
5. Fish McBites
The last item on this list had a brief run. Fish McBites were small pieces of battered whitefish, served in snack-size portions. The Wikipedia list says they were taken off the menu at the end of March 2013.
The bite-sized fish never earned the staying power of the Filet-O-Fish, which has held its place on the menu for decades. Today Fish McBites come up mostly among fans who remember trying them during their short run.
They are hardly alone. The company’s history is full of experiments that came and went. One of the best known is the Arch Deluxe, a burger aimed at adult tastes that launched in 1996 with a high-profile advertising campaign and is now considered one of the most expensive failures in the chain’s history. It eventually slipped off the menu as well, a sign that even a big marketing push does not always win over diners.
The 5 items here, from the McPizza and Hula Burger to the fried apple pie, Chicken Selects and Fish McBites, are rarely seen anymore. Some live on only in old commercials and family stories, which is often exactly where the best food memories are kept.
This article was produced with AI assistance and edited for accuracy against the sources linked above.
Image: Jeremy Thompson – CC BY 2.0/Wikimedia Commons