Every storm season, the same scene plays out in kitchens across the country. The lights come back on, the family heads for the pantry shelf of soup, beans and canned fruit that was bought “just in case,” and somebody pulls out a can with a dent in its side and wonders whether it still counts.
According to Ready.gov, the federal preparedness site run by FEMA, it does not. Its food safety guidance for emergencies says not to eat food from cans that are swollen, dented or corroded, even when the product inside looks fine. The same page names 5 more kinds of food that belong in the trash after a storm or power outage.

Why damaged cans come off the shelf first
A can is only as good as its seal. Commercial canning works by heating food inside an airtight container so it keeps on the shelf for a long time without refrigeration. A swollen lid, a deep dent along a seam or rust that has eaten into the metal are all signs that seal may no longer be doing its job. Ready.gov’s wording is direct: skip those cans “even though the product may look safe to eat.”
That makes a quick shelf check part of storm prep, not just storm cleanup. Many households rotate their emergency food once or twice a year, using up older cans in regular meals and replacing them with fresh ones. Pulling any damaged cans during that rotation keeps them from ending up in a pot when the power is out and options are limited. Families building up the rest of their emergency plan may also find practical help in this guide to building an emergency fund, since a stocked pantry and a cash cushion tend to go hand in hand.
1. Food that looks or smells abnormal, even in a normal can
A perfect-looking can is not a free pass. Ready.gov says not to eat any food that looks or smells abnormal, even if the can looks normal. If a can of green beans opens with an odd smell, or chili looks foamy or discolored, the rule is to throw it out rather than cook it longer or cover it with seasoning.
Tidy storage makes these checks easier. Shelves where every can is visible, labels face forward and the oldest items sit in front are easier to inspect quickly, and these clever storage hacks offer a few ideas for tight pantries.
2. Anything that touched floodwater
Ready.gov says to throw away any food that has come into contact with contaminated floodwater. That applies to boxed and bagged foods, produce and items stored in low cabinets or on a garage floor. Floodwater can carry sewage, chemicals and debris, and it can seep into packaging that is not fully sealed. Pantries in basements or garages are the most exposed, which is one reason preparedness planners suggest keeping emergency food up high and in sealed bins, as covered in these seasonal storage practices.

3. Food left at room temperature for 2 hours or more
Ready.gov tells households to throw away any food that has been at room temperature for 2 hours or more. The reason is the temperature range the site calls out: bacteria in food grow rapidly between 40 and 140 degrees Fahrenheit. A casserole left on the counter during a long outage, or a container of cut fruit forgotten on the table, falls into this category once the clock passes 2 hours.
4. Food with an unusual odor, color or texture
This one covers everything in the kitchen, not only cans. Ready.gov says to throw away any food with an unusual odor, color or texture. Slimy deli meat, sour milk, cheese that has changed color and bread with spots all qualify. The government’s food safety site, FoodSafety.gov, adds a firm line in its power outage guidance: never taste food to decide whether it is safe.
5. Perishables above 40°F for 2 hours
The fifth item is the one that hits the refrigerator hardest. Ready.gov says to discard perishable foods such as meat, poultry, fish, eggs and leftovers that have been above 40°F for 2 hours or more. Timing matters here. Ready.gov says an unopened refrigerator keeps food cold for about 4 hours, and FoodSafety.gov says a full freezer holds a safe temperature for about 48 hours, or about 24 hours if it is half full and the door stays closed.
That is why the advice during an outage is to keep refrigerator and freezer doors shut as much as possible. Practical reminders for getting through a cold-weather outage are also collected in this list of things never to do alone in a winter power outage.
What belongs in the pantry instead
The other side of the list is what to keep. Ready.gov recommends storing at least a several-day supply of non-perishable food, including canned foods, dry mixes and other staples that do not need refrigeration, cooking, water or special preparation. It also suggests choosing foods the family will actually eat, and its emergency kit checklist includes a manual can opener for food.
The American Red Cross goes further on quantities. Its survival kit checklist calls for non-perishable, easy-to-prepare food and 1 gallon of water per person per day, with a 3-day supply for evacuation and a 2-week supply for home. The debate over whether 3 days is enough is explored in this piece on the 72-hour emergency recommendation.
The short version of Ready.gov’s advice fits on an index card taped inside the pantry door: no swollen, dented or corroded cans, nothing that looks or smells wrong, nothing that touched floodwater, nothing left out 2 hours or more, nothing with an odd odor, color or texture, and no perishables above 40°F for 2 hours. When in doubt, throw it out.
This article was produced with AI assistance and edited for accuracy against the sources linked above.
Image: Cjp24 – CC BY-SA 4.0/Wikimedia Commons