Every family has the one Thanksgiving dish that guests from out of state stare at before they taste it. For some households it is a bowl of sauerkraut next to the turkey; for others it is a pan of potatoes crowned with crushed cornflakes.
With Thanksgiving falling on Thursday, Nov. 26, 2026, here are 6 side dishes that rarely travel far beyond their home turf, drawn from a state-by-state roundup that Atlas Obscura published on Nov. 20, 2021 from its Gastro Obscura readers, plus the long-running regional notes in the Wikipedia entry on Thanksgiving dinner.
1. Baltimore Sauerkraut
In much of the country, sauerkraut belongs with hot dogs and bratwurst. In Baltimore, it shows up on the Thanksgiving table. The Wikipedia entry on the holiday meal notes that sauerkraut is sometimes served in the Mid-Atlantic, especially by Baltimoreans of German and Eastern European descent.
The pairing makes more sense than it first sounds. The sharp, sour cabbage cuts through a plate loaded with gravy, buttery mashed potatoes and rich stuffing. Families who grew up with it tend to describe a Thanksgiving without the kraut as missing something, even if visiting cousins pass it by.
The dish also says a lot about how immigrant food traditions settle into an American holiday. Rather than replacing the turkey, the sauerkraut simply took a seat next to it, the same way other families tuck in a favorite dish from home. Plenty of households have their own quirks along those lines, as a list of strange Thanksgiving traditions everyone pretends are normal makes clear.
2. Minnesota Wild Rice Casserole
Atlas Obscura names wild rice casserole as Minnesota’s signature Thanksgiving side. The dish leans on a grain with deep roots in the region. Wild rice, called manoomin in the Ojibwe language, has long been harvested by the Ojibwe and other Native peoples, and Atlas Obscura describes it as North America’s only native grain.
According to the Wikipedia entry on wild rice, harvesters traditionally paddle a canoe into a stand of plants and use two small wooden sticks called knockers to bend the ripe heads so the grain falls into the boat. Wild rice is also Minnesota’s official state grain.
On the holiday table, the grain often turns up baked with mushrooms, onions and a creamy binder, giving it a nutty, chewy texture that sets it apart from a bread stuffing. Even so, bread stuffing remains the bigger draw nationally, ranking as the favorite Thanksgiving side in 38 states.
3. Utah Funeral Potatoes
Few side dishes have a name that stops conversation quite like funeral potatoes. Atlas Obscura lists them as Utah’s dish: a cheesy potato casserole finished with a crunchy cornflake topping. The name comes from how often the casserole appears at potlucks after funerals, especially in Latter-day Saint communities.
The Wikipedia entry on funeral potatoes describes a typical version built from hash browns or cubed potatoes, cheddar cheese, onions, a cream soup or sauce, and sour cream, topped with butter and crushed cornflakes, crackers or potato chips. It also goes by Mormon funeral potatoes and, in Iowa, party potatoes.
The dish has an unexpected bit of Olympic history, too. During the 2002 Winter Olympics in Salt Lake City, one of the souvenir collector pins depicted funeral potatoes. Because the casserole can be assembled a day ahead, it is also a practical way to free up oven space, a common holiday headache that has some cooks weighing an air fryer or toaster oven for Thanksgiving.
4. Frog Eye Salad in Colorado, Idaho, Nevada and Wyoming
Despite the name, there are no frogs involved. Atlas Obscura ties frog eye salad to Colorado, Idaho, Nevada and Wyoming, describing it as a sweet pasta salad made with small pasta, Cool Whip and pineapple. The “frog eyes” are the tiny round pasta beads that dot the bowl.
What surprises newcomers is where it sits. Rather than waiting for the dessert course, frog eye salad is often served alongside the savory dishes, right next to the turkey and potatoes. It belongs to a broader family of creamy, fruit-studded salads that were a fixture of mid-century church suppers, the same era that gave the country many of the foods from the 1960s that boomers loved.
5. California Persimmon Bread
In California, Atlas Obscura points to persimmon bread. The timing explains the habit: Thanksgiving often lands at the peak of persimmon season, when backyard trees produce more fruit than a household can eat fresh.
Bakers turn the soft, ripe fruit into a spiced quick bread, similar in spirit to banana bread, that works on the dinner table or with coffee the next morning. It is a classic example of a regional dish shaped less by tradition than by what happens to be piling up on the kitchen counter in late November. Clearing that counter before guests arrive is a job of its own, and a list of oven checks to make before the turkey goes in is worth a look for anyone hosting.
6. Texas and Oklahoma Sopapilla Cheesecake
The last dish on the list crosses the line into dessert. Atlas Obscura credits Texas and Oklahoma with sopapilla cheesecake, made by spreading cheesecake filling over unrolled crescent dough. The dough bakes into a flaky crust that resembles crispy sopapillas, the puffy fried pastries described in the Wikipedia entry on sopaipillas.
Many home versions finish with a layer of butter, cinnamon and sugar on top, giving the pan a crackly, churro-like crust. It is easy to make in a big batch, which helps explain why it shows up at so many family gatherings in the two states.
Why Regional Sides Hold On
Turkey is nearly universal on the fourth Thursday of November, but the sides are where families and regions put their stamp on the meal. The Wikipedia entry on Thanksgiving dinner also lists cornbread dressing across the South and lefse among families of Scandinavian descent in the Midwest and Pacific Northwest.
Those 6 dishes, from Baltimore sauerkraut to Utah’s funeral potatoes, rarely appear on tables outside their home regions. For families who grew up with them, though, they are not quirky at all. They are simply what Thanksgiving tastes like.
This article was produced with AI assistance and edited for accuracy against the sources linked above.
Image: Pingnova – CC0/Wikimedia Commons