Anne Fishel, co-founder and executive director of The Family Dinner Project, keeps the turkey and the sweet potatoes the same every Thanksgiving. Then she adds at least one dish her family has never made before.
The habit comes from an essay by Bri DeRosa, published Nov. 1, 2025, on the nonprofit’s website and in its November 2025 newsletter. Fishel told DeRosa that her family honors its recipes for turkey and sweet potatoes but chooses at least one wholly new dish to try as part of the feast. Thanksgiving this year falls on Nov. 26. The federal holiday is celebrated on the fourth Thursday of November, according to Wikipedia.

The Rule at the Fishel Table
The rule is short. Two recipes stay fixed, and the rest of the menu has room for at least one surprise. In the Thanksgiving Traditions, Old and New essay, Fishel does not name the new dishes, and she does not describe a formula for picking them. The point, as she explains it, is the habit of including something unfamiliar. A new dish that needs its own oven time is easier with a comparison of air fryers and a toaster oven that free up the main oven.
By always including something unfamiliar, Fishel said in the essay, her family is rehearsing for other, more substantial changes to come. She summed up the practice in two words: “welcoming novelty” is part of the family’s tradition.
That fits her view of what a tradition is. The project’s team page lists Fishel as executive director and co-founder, and the essay quotes her on rituals in general. DeRosa wrote that Fishel explained traditions through the lens of rituals, which stay consistent in timing, place and predictable elements, but have some parts that can change from year to year.
Why Tradition Leaves Room for Change
Fishel described Thanksgiving as a ritual that gives families “an intergenerational thread.” In her words, it reminds people that they belong to something larger than any one household, for example by eating food that earlier generations cooked or telling stories about relatives who are no longer there. She called it an opportunity for remembrance as well as gratitude.
She also said traditions bring stability and continuity, which can matter most during times of stress or change. But keeping things absolutely the same is not required. “Many life events, both positive and negative, may prompt families to shift, amend, upend, or retire a longstanding ritual,” Fishel said, adding that keeping familiar rituals while accommodating change is a recurring challenge over a family’s life.
The essay’s closing thoughts lean the same way. Fishel noted that “new” and “tradition” are really opposite words, and only time will tell whether a new practice becomes a tradition. DeRosa’s own summary was that every tradition was just an idea, or a recipe, once. A lighter look at the same theme appears in a roundup of strange Thanksgiving traditions that families keep without a second thought, and a list of 3 zodiac signs said to hold family traditions dearest presents the subject as entertainment rather than research.

How One Family Handed Out the Menu
A Family Dinner Spotlight on the Lang family, published by the project in January 2015, shows another way a family can shape a Thanksgiving. Suzanne Lang recalled that, a week or two before her son Alec left for freshman year of college, he announced from the car that he really wanted Thanksgiving at their house that year. He also wanted to be in charge. Alec arrived with a specific menu in mind and an agenda.
“He immediately started thinking about what everyone’s strong suits were and how they could contribute,” his mother said. In the spotlight, she recalled him saying that one relative was good at pie and that Aunt Karen’s turnips were a favorite, so that was what each should bring. Suzanne suspected the planning gave him something to look forward to while staying connected to the family dinner ritual he had grown up with.
Hosting at that scale calls for some preparation of its own, and a checklist of 5 home checks to finish before Thanksgiving houseguests arrive covers the practical side. Guests who linger after dinner may also want coffee, which is the subject of a comparison of single-cup and full-pot coffee makers for holiday guests.
A Large, Loud Table in the Same Essay
DeRosa frames the question around her own table. She writes that a relative who once skipped the holiday and booked a vacation instead will be at her Thanksgiving this year, at what she describes as a very large, loud, pleasantly chaotic traditional meal. Some families step away from the holiday for a year or longer, she observed, and some fractured families are willing to give one another a chance again.
Her takeaway for families who want to continue a tradition is practical. It may be worth looking at things with a fresh eye and considering whether any small updates would make the day feel more fun and meaningful. A family returning after time away can see how the old traditions feel and perhaps introduce something new to mark the moment. Families wanting a whole new way of celebrating, she wrote, get to create a tradition of their own.
Where to Find More Thanksgiving Ideas
The Family Dinner Project keeps a Thanksgiving hub, which its Getting Ready for Thanksgiving newsletter for November 2026 describes as a place to find resources for a day of food, fun and conversation. The hub includes holiday conversation starters, group games, low-budget recipes and advice on managing tricky family dynamics. This year it added tips for the days before the holiday, and the newsletter also points to a Friendsgiving guide for celebrations with friends.
Budget-minded hosts have another option in the project’s budget-friendly Thanksgiving list, which collects 10 recipes at under $1, under $2 and under $3 per serving. The project says it tracked those prices in October 2025, so the figures may have shifted since. Its list includes a Thanksgiving meatball recipe and an eggnog cake, a reminder that a new dish does not have to be expensive to earn a spot at the table.
This article was produced with AI assistance and edited for accuracy against the sources linked above.
Image: Infrogmation – CC BY-SA 4.0/Wikimedia Commons