The spice jar that has lived in the cabinet over the stove since the last holiday looks fine. The label is faded, the lid is a little sticky, and the cinnamon inside smells like very little. That is the moment a pantry layout starts to matter.
An Ohio State University Extension fact sheet says cabinets above the range, beside the dishwasher or next to the refrigerator exhaust run too warm for food. Its pantry chart then gives ground spices 6 months and whole spices 1 to 2 years at 70°F. Those two facts together explain why placement and shelf life belong in the same conversation, and the sources do not all agree on the numbers, as the sections below show.
Why Some Cabinets Run Too Warm for Food
The Ohio State fact sheet, Pantry Food Storage (HYG-5401), is dated Dec. 9, 2010, so it is older reference material rather than a new announcement. It was written by Lesley Fisher and Lydia Medeiros of the university’s extension program. It says cabinets tend to be warmer above the range, near the dishwasher, or next to the refrigerator exhaust, and calls them good places for dishes, pots and pans but too warm for food.
The same sheet gives a general rule for cans: do not keep canned goods longer than one year, and keep them at moderately cool, but not freezing, temperatures. Canned foods stored above 70°F will have a shorter shelf life, and cans should not be stored above 95°F, such as in a shed or garage. A kitchen that is easy to reorganize is a big help here, this roundup of storage hacks for every inch of a home offers ideas for finding the room, and this guide to easy kitchen remodel ideas on a shoestring budget shows how little it can take to rethink where things go.
The Numbers: Ground Spices 6 Months, Whole Spices 1 to 2 Years
The headline figures come from the chart in the Ohio State sheet, which lists recommended storage time at 70°F. Ground spices and herbs are given 6 months. Whole spices and herbs are given 1 to 2 years, with the handling hint to store them in airtight containers in dry places away from sunlight and heat. The chart adds a freshness test: check the aroma, and if it has faded, replace the spice. It also says whole cloves, nutmeg and cinnamon sticks keep their quality beyond the 2-year period.
Other items on the same chart show how much storage times can differ. Coffee is listed at 2 years unopened but 2 weeks opened, and vanilla at 2 years unopened and 12 months opened, with the hint to keep it tightly closed because volatile oils escape.
Where the Sources Differ
The fact sheet is not consistent with itself. In its text, it says the shelf life of whole spices is 2 years and of ground spices and dried herbs is one year. The chart says 6 months for ground. America’s Test Kitchen’s guide to keeping spices fresher longer lands on the text version: whole spices at two years, and ground spices and dried herbs best within a year of buying them.
A third view comes from the trade. Tasting Table’s guide to storing spices quotes McCormick executive chef Hadar Cohen Aviram, who says ground spices such as cumin or paprika last two to four years if properly stored, and leafy herbs one to three years. The same piece quotes Ethan Frisch of Burlap & Barrel saying spices do not go bad exactly but diminish in intensity.
The practical reading is that the printed numbers describe when flavor starts to fade, not a hard stop. A faded aroma is the signal that matters in all three sources, and a permanent-marker date on the jar, which Aviram recommends, makes the clock visible.

Where to Put Spices Instead
All three sources point in the same direction on location. Ohio State says not to store spices on the counter close to the stove because heat and light shorten their shelf life. America’s Test Kitchen says to keep spices in a cool, dry place and away from the counter or stove, since heat, light and moisture cut shelf life. Tasting Table’s experts name light, moisture and heat as the main culprits of flavor loss and recommend a spice drawer, a cabinet away from the stove, or a rack kept out of direct sunlight. Neither of its experts recommends the fridge, with Aviram saying a freezer flavor can settle in.
That makes a simple map for a kitchen. The cabinets next to the range and dishwasher suit pots, pans and plates. A drawer, or a cabinet on the far side of the room, suits jars, and sealed containers have a long kitchen history of their own, told in craftingyourhome.com’s piece on Brownie Wise and the Tupperware party. Households that want to think through the holiday kitchen can also check the craftingyourhome.com list of kitchen checks before Thanksgiving dinner on Nov. 26.
A Short Pantry History and a Holiday Note
The idea of a separate place for dry goods is old. Wikipedia’s entry on the pantry traces the word to the Old French paneterie, from the word for bread, and describes the medieval pantry as a dry room where bread was kept. The entry also notes that American pantries grew out of colonial butteries built in a cold north corner of a house, which is a reminder that cool and dry placement is not a new idea. Wikipedia’s entry on spices adds the background on what the category covers.
Holiday baking is when spice jars come out of hiding, and it is also when old jars get discovered. A cook who opens a cinnamon jar on Nov. 21 and finds it dull has a clear option under the sources above: check the aroma, replace it if faded, and move the new jar to a cooler cupboard. Anyone curious about how other holiday habits look to outsiders may enjoy this roundup of odd American traditions that confuse the rest of the world.
The takeaway from Ohio State’s sheet is short: a warm cabinet is a poor home for food, ground spices run about 6 months in a cool cupboard on the chart, and whole spices run 1 to 2 years. The cans in the same pantry follow a one-year guideline. Dates, labels and a sniff test do the rest, and the figures here reflect the sources as read on Nov. 21, 2026.
This article was produced with AI assistance and edited for accuracy against the sources linked above.
Image: Mx. Granger – CC0/Wikimedia Commons