Stuffing Is the Top Thanksgiving Side in 38 States, Mashed Potatoes in 6 and Mac and Cheese in 4, Campbell’s Report Says

Every Thanksgiving table has a quiet argument about the sides. Somebody insists the meal is not complete without stuffing, somebody else would trade the turkey for a bowl of mashed potatoes, and a third relative arrives with a casserole of macaroni and cheese and defends it with a straight face.

A state-by-state map now puts numbers on that argument. Stuffing is the top Thanksgiving side in 38 states, mashed potatoes lead in 6 and mac and cheese leads in 4, according to Campbell’s 2026 State of the Sides report, as mapped by Mental Floss on Nov. 12, 2026.

A bowl of mashed potatoes set out for Thanksgiving dinner
Famartin – CC BY-SA 4.0/Wikimedia Commons

Stuffing leads in 38 states

Jenny Cohen’s Mental Floss map of the most popular Thanksgiving sides by state says stuffing, which some households call dressing, is the top side nationally and the favorite in 38 states. Utah is the one tie, with stuffing and mashed potatoes sharing the top spot. The article says 12 states chose something other than stuffing, a count that includes Utah’s tie, which leaves 11 states with a different outright favorite.

The report’s source is Campbell’s, the soup company, and Mental Floss links the report as a PDF. The article does not give the survey method or sample size, so the map is best read as one company’s snapshot of table habits, not a census.

The name on the dish varies by region. The Wikipedia entry on stuffing says “dressing” became the more common term in the United States, with a recorded use from 1850, while “stuffing” dates to 1538. The entry adds that a stuffing cooked separately as a side dish may be called either name, and that the earliest written evidence of the idea appears in a Roman cookbook attributed to Apicius.

Why side dish traditions stick

Thanksgiving falls on the fourth Thursday of November, which is Nov. 26 this year, according to the Wikipedia entry on the holiday, and its sides are less about taste tests and more about family memory. A relative’s stuffing recipe or a cousin’s mac and cheese can hold a table together for decades, and a look at strange Thanksgiving traditions that everyone pretends are not weird shows how particular such customs can get. Another piece on odd American traditions that confuse the rest of the world places the holiday meal among the country’s most distinctive habits.

Planning helps with sides that fill the oven. A guide to kitchen checks before Thanksgiving dinner on Nov. 26 covers the pre-holiday inventory, and a short history of the Thanksgiving masking tradition shows how much of the day has changed over time.

Mashed potatoes lead in 6 states

Mental Floss lists six states where mashed potatoes take first place: California, Indiana, Iowa, Kansas, Nebraska and West Virginia. Mashed potatoes rank second nationally, the article says, in the same order as the past three years.

The dish has a long history in print. According to the Wikipedia entry on mashed potato, Hannah Glasse’s The Art of Cookery included an early recipe in 1747 that mashed potatoes in a saucepan with milk, salt and butter. The entry lists variations from duchess potatoes in France to mukimo in Kenya, which shows how widely the humble mash travels.

A holiday table that leans on mashed potatoes also leans on the oven and the stove at once, which is a common crunch. A comparison of countertop appliances that free up the oven shows one way hosts handle the traffic jam.

A baking dish of macaroni and cheese
Martin – CC BY 2.0/Wikimedia Commons

Mac and cheese leads in 4 states

Four states put macaroni and cheese first, according to the map: New York, Texas, Georgia and North Carolina. Mental Floss reports that New York is the only state to rank mac and cheese first two years in a row. The article also cites Campbell’s finding that mac and cheese appears on 67 percent of Southeastern tables, with almost 80 percent of Georgia residents planning to serve it.

Louisiana is the lone state where sweet potatoes come out on top, according to the same map. Between the 38 stuffing states, Utah’s tie, the 6 mashed potato states, the 4 mac and cheese states and Louisiana, the count reaches all 50.

The dish is older than most people expect. The Wikipedia entry on macaroni and cheese traces a baked version to Elizabeth Raffald’s 1769 cookbook and says Thomas Jefferson served “a pie called macaroni” at a state dinner in 1802. Kraft began producing its boxed version in 1937, the entry says, and wartime rationing in the 1940s increased its popularity.

How many sides the average table holds

The report also counts sides. Campbell’s says the average Thanksgiving table has at least four, and the national average is just under six sides, which adds up to almost 750 million sides a year, as Mental Floss relays it. Florida averages the most at 9.1 sides, followed by Kentucky at about 8.4, while Maryland averages 5.1 and Colorado 4.9.

Regional favorites show up beyond the top spot. Green bean casserole appears on 60 percent of Midwestern tables, led by Nebraska and Missouri, the article says. Together, the numbers describe a meal where the sides, not the turkey, carry the regional personality.

The simple version of the map: stuffing in 38 states, mashed potatoes in 6, mac and cheese in 4, sweet potatoes in 1, and Utah split between the first two. A host wondering what to put on the table can use the local favorite as a starting point, with the caveat that Mental Floss does not say how many people were asked.

This article was produced with AI assistance and edited for accuracy against the sources linked above.

Author

More Posts You May love

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *