Apples Should Never Share a Storage Bin With Potatoes or Carrots, Because Ethylene Makes Potatoes Sprout and Apples Taste Musty

A bag of apples and a sack of potatoes often end up side by side in the same cool corner of a garage, basement or pantry each fall. Extension experts say that pairing is one of the easiest storage mistakes to fix.

North Carolina State Extension puts it bluntly: apples should never be stored with potatoes or carrots. Apples give off ethylene gas, which can cause sprouting and bitterness in those vegetables, and potatoes in turn can leave apples with a musty flavor.

Bins of fresh apples for sale at a produce stand
PumpkinSky – CC BY-SA 3.0/Wikimedia Commons

What the extension guidance says

The warning comes from “Winter Storage of Fruits and Vegetables,” written by Eli Snyder of N.C. Cooperative Extension’s Caldwell County Center and updated Dec. 9, 2024. It says to “never store apples with potatoes or carrots as they produce ethylene, and will cause bitterness and sprouting.” The same guide adds that potatoes “can lend a musty flavor to apples when stored together.”

That makes the problem a two-way street. The apples harm the potatoes and carrots, and the potatoes harm the apples. Two different things are going on, though. Ethylene from the fruit pushes the vegetables to sprout or turn bitter, while the musty taste in the apples comes from odors they pick up from the potatoes.

Iowa State University Extension backs up the sprouting side. Its answer on why stored potatoes sprout, last updated July 30, 2024, says not to store potatoes with apples or other fruits because fruits produce ethylene gas, and “Ethylene promotes sprouting of potatoes.” It adds that tubers often begin to sprout when storage temperatures climb above 50 degrees Fahrenheit, and it recommends about 40 degrees with 90 to 95 percent relative humidity.

Storage spaces that work well for one crop do not always suit another. Home gardeners who keep harvesting into the cold months with elevated garden beds for fall greens and herbs often face the same question of where everything goes once it is picked. Good habits pay off at every stage, from dealing with the worst garden pests in summer to starting new plants like lavender from seed in spring, and storage is the last step of that cycle.

How ethylene works

Ethylene is a simple gas that plants use as a natural ripening signal. According to Wikipedia’s entry on ethylene as a plant hormone, it acts on fruit ripening, the opening of flowers and the shedding of leaves, and many fruits release more of it as they ripen.

That effect can be useful. Cornell University’s guide to ripening green tomatoes indoors explains that ethylene released from ripening fruit will stimulate other fruit to ripen, and it suggests adding a ripe tomato, a banana or an apple to a box of green tomatoes to speed things up. In a root-vegetable bin, the same gas simply causes trouble.

Apples are a common source of ethylene in home kitchens, which is why where they sit matters. A fruit bowl next to a basket of potatoes on the counter can create the same problem on a smaller scale as a shared storage bin in the basement. Kitchen rules like this one are simple once they are known, much like the list of everyday kitchen items that should never go in a dishwasher, and garage storage has its own list of things never to leave in an unheated garage once freezing weather arrives.

A potato with several sprouts growing from its eyes
ZooFari – Public domain/Wikimedia Commons

Apples absorb odors, too

Washington State University Extension in Snohomish County adds another reason to keep the two apart. It says apples, pears, grapes and other fruits “can absorb odors from potatoes and other vegetables.” It also warns that apples and potatoes stored together produce ethylene that can make both spoil.

For long-term storage, WSU says apples should be kept as close to 32 degrees as possible without freezing, since they become overripe quickly at 70 degrees or above. They need moderate moisture to keep from shriveling, but too much humidity encourages decay, so storage bags should have ventilation holes rather than being sealed tight.

Freezing weather brings its own problems for anything kept in an outbuilding. A garage that stays cold enough for apples can also drop below freezing on the worst nights, so a thermometer near the storage spot is a cheap way to keep track.

Where each one should go instead

The fix is separation, not a special container. Based on the extension guidance, a simple home setup looks like this:

  • Apples: as cold as possible without freezing, close to 32 degrees, in bags with air holes, ideally in a refrigerator drawer or a separate cold room away from vegetables.
  • Potatoes: dark, humid and cool, about 40 degrees per Iowa State, or 45 to 50 degrees per NC State, out of the light, which can cause green spots, and away from fruit.
  • Carrots: NC State notes that fall-planted carrots can stay in the garden under about a foot of straw or dried leaves once freezes are forecast.
  • Cabbage family crops: NC State suggests storing cabbages and turnips outdoors, since they can give off strong odors indoors.

The “never” has a practical limit. The goal is to keep the gas and the odors from building up around each other, so separate crisper drawers, separate shelves with good air flow or separate rooms all count as not sharing a bin. A tight bin or closed bag holding apples and potatoes together is the setup to avoid.

A small change for a long winter

Separating the two crops costs nothing and saves food over a long season. Each crop simply lasts better in its own spot, at its own temperature and humidity.

Moving the apples to their own cold spot takes a few minutes. It helps potatoes and carrots hold off sprouting and bitterness, and it helps the apples keep their clean, fresh flavor.

This article was produced with AI assistance and edited for accuracy against the sources linked above.

Image: George Chernilevsky – Public domain/Wikimedia Commons

Author

More Posts You May love

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *