The potato bag sits next to the stove, the onions are in a bowl on the counter, and a butternut squash has been waiting on the windowsill since October. Nothing looks wrong until the first potato sprouts or the garlic goes soft.
The U.S. Environmental Protection Agency names five pantry produce items that belong in one kind of spot: potatoes, onions, garlic, winter squash and eggplant. The agency says they keep best in a cool, dry, dark, well-ventilated place. That one sentence from EPA’s page on wasted food at home covers a whole shelf of groceries, and extension sources add the numbers.

What EPA Says About the Five Items
EPA’s guidance on wasted food at home lists the five by name: potatoes, eggplant, winter squash, onions and garlic. The wording is short: store them in a cool, dry, dark and well-ventilated place. Other produce on the same page goes to the refrigerator, with leafy greens and carrots in the high-humidity drawer and fruit in the low-humidity drawer, so these five are the exceptions that stay out of the fridge.
The page ties storage to money. EPA says the average family of four spends almost $3,000 per year on food that does not get eaten, and recommends checking the fridge, freezer and pantry before shopping and planning meals around what needs to be used up. An EPA news release dated Nov. 24, 2020 made the same shop-the-pantry-first point for Thanksgiving week. That release is nearly six years old, so it is cited only for the agency’s standing advice.
Potatoes: Dark, Ventilated and Away From Onions
The Iowa State University Extension guide to storing winter storage vegetables adds detail for potatoes. It says to store them in a dark location because they turn green when exposed to light, and that above 50°F the tubers may begin to sprout in two to three months. Below 40°F, it says, potatoes develop a sugary, sweet taste, which can fade after a few days at room temperature. It gives an average storage life for potatoes of 5 to 8 months when stored appropriately.
Iowa State also says not to store potatoes with apples or other fruit, because ripening fruit gives off ethylene gas, which promotes sprouting. The Farmers’ Almanac guide to storing potatoes, onions and garlic, which lists a 2026 update, adds a related rule: keep potatoes away from onions, because the two give off gases that speed each other toward sprouting and soft spots. It also says never to wash potatoes before storing them, since the added moisture invites rot. Households that like to keep a garden growing late may enjoy this look at elevated garden beds for fall greens and herbs.
Onions and Garlic: Mesh Bags and Moving Air
Iowa State’s guide says onions should go in a container that lets air circulate, such as a mesh bag, wire basket or crate, in a cool, moderately dry location at 32 to 40°F and 65 to 70% relative humidity. It gives an average storage life of 5 to 8 months. For garlic, it says to trim the dry foliage, brush off loose soil, and keep the bulbs in a mesh bag or open crate at 32 to 40°F, with an average storage life of 6 to 7 months.
The Farmers’ Almanac says much the same about airflow, recommending a mesh bag or ventilated crate for onions and a hung braid for garlic. Both sources match EPA’s wording on ventilation, which is the part of the rule most kitchens miss when produce is sealed in a plastic bag.

Winter Squash and Eggplant
Winter squash gets its own numbers from Iowa State, which says to store it in a cool, dry, well-ventilated location at 50 to 55°F, and not near apples, pears or other ripening fruit because ethylene gas shortens its storage life. When properly dried out and stored, it gives approximate storage lives of 5 to 8 weeks for acorn squash, 2 to 3 months for butternut and 5 to 6 months for Hubbard. That means the squash on the windowsill can wait a while, but acorn squash is the one to use first.
Eggplant is on EPA’s list but not covered in the Iowa State guide, so the only source for it here is EPA’s cool, dry, dark and well-ventilated rule. No storage-time figure for eggplant comes from the sources used, and none is offered.
Why Cool Does Not Mean the Same Number
The extension numbers show that cool is a range, not one setting. Iowa State gives 50 to 55°F for squash, 32 to 40°F for onions and garlic, and about 40°F for potatoes once they have been conditioned, which is why a single unheated pantry, cellar or closet is a compromise. Wikipedia’s entry on the root cellar says optimal temperature and humidity ranges vary by crop, and that a few crops keep better in low humidity, which describes onions and garlic.
A practical layout follows from that. A dark shelf away from the stove and dishwasher suits the squash, a ventilated basket suits the onions and garlic, and a separate box suits the potatoes. The craftingyourhome.com checklist of kitchen checks before Thanksgiving dinner on Nov. 26 is a good moment to reset that shelf, and another craftingyourhome.com piece explains what officials say to keep on hand for a black sky event, where shelf-stable pantry foods matter.
Anyone looking for more ways to fit a stocked pantry into a small kitchen can browse this roundup of storage hacks for every inch of a home, and a Thanksgiving host curious about holiday customs may enjoy this piece on odd American traditions that confuse the rest of the world.
The five items in EPA’s list are potatoes, onions, garlic, winter squash and eggplant, and the rule is the same for all of them: cool, dry, dark and ventilated. The numbers from Iowa State and the Farmers’ Almanac refine it, and the details here reflect those sources as read on Nov. 21, 2026.
This article was produced with AI assistance and edited for accuracy against the sources linked above.
Image: Ruslan V. Albitsky – CC BY-SA 3.0/Wikimedia Commons