Most diners in America sit down expecting to do a little math at the end of the meal: look at the total, pick a tip, sign the slip. At a handful of Ford’s Garage restaurants in Florida, that last step has been made for them, and not everyone has liked it.
Ford’s Garage president Billy Downs told Fox News Digital that the chain may encourage a change to a 20% automatic service charge being tested by one franchisee at 5 Florida locations, after some customers pushed back on the mandatory fee. He said the company needs to listen to diners on the issue, and that no decision has been made yet.

What the Chain President Said
In the interview, published on Nov. 14, 2026, by Fox News Digital, Downs said the policy remains under review. In his words, the company may be “encouraging a change to that program.” He described the test as a way to see whether a different pay model could keep costs down for guests while rewarding servers.
Downs was candid about the reaction. He said there have been “some big wins,” but also diners who simply do not want to pay a service charge. He added that the biggest complaint is the mandatory nature of the fee, and admitted that there are times when he is not sure he would want one either. The company talks about it regularly, he said, but had not settled on anything.
Where the money on a restaurant check goes, and who decides, is a very American puzzle. Tipping culture regularly lands on lists of American traditions that confuse the rest of the world. The holiday season piles on more of those decisions, from restaurant meals with family to holiday tips for housekeepers, nannies and dog walkers.
How the 20% Charge Works
The charge belongs to a team service model from 23 Restaurant Services, a Tampa-based company that runs Ford’s Garage restaurants across Florida. Instead of relying on traditional tips, the model adds 20% to every check to fund a commission-based pay setup. Servers and bartenders earn commissions on sales, and the model is also meant to share pay more evenly with kitchen and support staff, according to the franchisee’s website as cited by Fox. Extra tips are optional.
The New York Post, which ran the same report on Nov. 14, noted that the Ford’s Garage in Plantation, near Fort Lauderdale, applies the charge “in lieu of a traditional gratuity.” That location also adds a separate 1% entertainment fee assessed by the shopping center, which the restaurant’s website says goes straight to the retail center and is not kept by Ford’s Garage or paid to employees.
For diners who grew up with simpler rules, it is a long way from the days when the tip was cash under the saucer. Some of those habits show up in a roundup of old-school etiquette rules that have disappeared. Money habits have shifted just as much, as a look at old-school money habits boomers used makes clear.
Diners have long had strong opinions about table manners on both sides of the check, and many of them turn up in lists of dining-out blunders to avoid.
The Franchisee’s Side
Marc Brown, president of 23 Restaurant Services, defended the program. He told Fox News Digital that servers at the locations with the service charge earn significantly higher average hourly pay than servers and bartenders at locations without it.
Brown said the charge is disclosed several times, both out loud and in writing, before guests order, so they can choose whether to stay. In his view, it is no different from charging a higher menu price. He said most guests are not bothered, because they like the Ford’s Garage experience, and that the criticism comes from a fairly small share of diners. Most of the participating restaurants, he added, have grown year over year after running the model for several years.
He also pushed back on the idea that a built-in charge makes staff less motivated, saying employees are expected to give great service to every guest no matter what extra tip they might receive.

Why Diners Push Back
The debate over who gets paid what at the table is not new. There is also a practical difference between a tip and a service charge. The IRS says service charges added to a bill by the employer and handed to an employee are not tips; the employer must count them as wages. The Wikipedia entry on gratuity adds that tipping may not be expected when a fee is clearly charged for service, which is the logic behind the Ford’s Garage test.
A Chain Built on Burgers and Old Cars
Ford’s Garage was founded in Fort Myers in 2012 and has grown to 36 restaurants across 9 states, Fox reported. The chain has a licensing deal with Ford Motor Company that lets it use the Ford name and logo, according to its Wikipedia entry, which also notes that most of its restaurants are run by 23 Restaurant Services. Downs told Fox that the chain focuses on value, with an average check of about $26 and weekday value meals starting at $10.99.
Why It Struck a Nerve
The fight over the 20% charge is really a fight over the bottom line on the check. The franchisee says the model pays staff better. Some customers, though, want the final say on the tip, even when the total comes out about the same.
For now, the charge stays in place at the 5 Florida restaurants while the chain weighs its options. Diners heading to one of those locations can expect to hear about it before ordering, and to see the 20% already added when the check arrives.
This article was produced with AI assistance and edited for accuracy against the sources linked above.