Moving out of a rental usually ends with a rushed scrub of the kitchen and a quiet hope that the deposit survives the inspection. Landlords and property managers tend to notice the same handful of things the moment they walk in.
Apartment Therapy collected comments from landlords, property managers and agents in a series of renter guides, and 8 kitchen habits come up again and again. Those guides were published between 2019 and 2022, so they read as long-standing advice rather than breaking news, and each item below names who said it. None of it replaces a lease, but all of it shows what a landlord sees first when the door opens on the kitchen.

Letting dishes and trash pile up
Lorinda Vorster, a property manager in Brisbane, Australia, told Apartment Therapy that dishes left for a few days, spoiled food and overfilled trash bins top her list of pet peeves. A kitchen that looks lived in is fine. One that looks abandoned for a week is the version that sticks in a landlord’s memory.
Using the oven as a heater
Cassidy Fyvie-Gillespie, a landlord who oversees nine units in Worcester, Massachusetts, said she does not like seeing people use their ovens as a source of heat. The Oregon State Fire Marshal’s cooking safety page is blunter: never use an oven to heat the home. It also advises keeping towels, oven mitts and packaging away from the stovetop, turning pot handles toward the back of the stove and keeping a lid nearby. For anyone cooking a holiday meal in a rental, ideas for freeing up oven space and kitchen checks before Thanksgiving dinner make the oven’s real job easier.
Crowding the countertops
Vorster also said she does not like seeing cluttered kitchen countertops. A packed counter hides stains and makes a unit look neglected during a walkthrough. Tidying up helps. A guide on items that should not be displayed on a kitchen counter is a good starting point, and clever kitchen tricks for home cooks help small spaces stay clear. Anyone itching to update a dated room can look at budget kitchen ideas before reaching for a drill or adhesive.
Ignoring a slow drain
Vorster said she has called a plumber a few times to unblock kitchen drains, which is a bill landlords would rather not pay twice. Grease is a frequent culprit. Clemson University Cooperative Extension says fats, oils and grease cool and solidify in household lines and can cause backups, and it advises collecting leftover grease in a can or bottle, capping it, letting it cool and putting it in the trash, then scraping pans and dishes with a paper towel before washing. A separate Apartment Therapy renter guide quotes New York agent Elias Marte saying the heat from chemical drain cleaners can warp or melt a pipe, and that a clogged drain is something to report to the landlord.
.jpg?width=1200)
Letting odors set in
Fyvie-Gillespie’s rule is simple: if a smell needs KILZ paint to cover it, the tenant does not get the deposit back. Odors soak into cabinets and walls, so spoiled food and a forgotten trash bin become a repair bill rather than a cleaning chore.
In Massachusetts, the state’s deposit guidance says a landlord may use a deposit for repair costs for damage caused by the tenant, other occupants or guests, but not for pre-existing damage or normal wear and tear. A landlord who keeps part of a deposit for damage must give an itemized list within the same 30-day period, or lose the right to keep any of it.
Leaving holes and broken cabinets
Fyvie-Gillespie says holes to patch, damaged floors or too many broken cabinets send a deposit toward repairs. Vorster adds that tenants will not get a deposit back if the property is not properly cleaned when they leave.
Hanging sticky fly catchers
“Sticky fly catchers hanging from the ceiling are never a good sign,” Fyvie-Gillespie said. Strips full of insects tell a landlord about pests more clearly than a note ever could. Apartment Therapy’s list pairs the habit with unmanaged ants, and the quicker a tenant reports a problem, the less likely it is to turn into a dispute at move-out.
Sticking on peel-and-stick backsplash tiles
Colby Hager, a San Antonio property manager, warned in another Apartment Therapy guide that peel-and-stick backsplash tiles can be sticky enough to damage the drywall behind them once peeled away. They look like an easy fix for a dated wall, but the cost shows up at move-out. Asking first, in writing, is the safer route, since a landlord who approves a change in advance is far less likely to count it as damage later. The same guide also cautions against overloading adhesive strips with heavy kitchen utensils, which can pull off the wall and leave holes.
A second Apartment Therapy list, 23 ways renters accidentally damage a rental, adds a few quieter kitchen mistakes. New York agent Rebecca Blacker said she has seen countertops with very noticeable burn marks from a hot pan not set on a trivet. The list also warns that pouring grease down the drain can gunk up pipes, that putting away wet dishes can warp cabinet wood, and that scrubbing marble with baking soda can wear away the sealant.
Apartment Therapy also notes that landlords prefer to hear about broken items during the lease rather than discover them afterward. Leases and local laws differ, so the lease itself is the final word.
This article was produced with AI assistance and edited for accuracy against the sources linked above.
Image: Joe Mabel – CC BY-SA 3.0/Wikimedia Commons