Couple With Kids 7 and 10 Torn Between Two Sets of Grandparents an Hour Away at Thanksgiving; Dear Annie Says Agree on a Plan Together

The turkey is not even in the oven yet, and the argument has already started. In one household, it begins every October, as soon as the first Thanksgiving question comes up: whose family gets the holiday this year?

That is the core of a letter published Nov. 4, 2026, in Annie Lane’s Dear Annie column, signed “Torn Between Two Turkeys.” A couple with two children, ages 7 and 10, is torn between two sets of grandparents, both about an hour away, who each expect the family at the table on Thanksgiving, which falls on Nov. 26 this year. The columnist’s answer: sit down together and agree on a plan.

A roasted turkey on a platter ready to carve
Mark Miller – CC BY-SA 4.0/Wikimedia Commons

Two Tables, Each With Its Own Hopes

According to the letter, as carried by Creators Syndicate, the writer and a husband have been married 12 years. The writer describes a mother who starts asking about plans weeks ahead, makes a huge dinner, loves having the grandchildren around and gets hurt when the family does not come. The letter says she has told the writer that a quiet Thanksgiving without the kids may be ahead.

The husband’s side is described as much the same. His mother, in the letter, insists that Thanksgiving is the one holiday when the entire family gets together, and his father recently told him that the grandparents will not be around forever. The writer is careful to say both families are loved, and that it is a gift for the children to have grandparents who want to spend time with them. The same letter also ran in the Anchorage Daily News and on ArcaMax.

What the Couple Has Already Tried

The letter lists two earlier fixes. Alternating years left whichever family was not hosting feeling cheated. Splitting the day, with lunch at one home and dinner at the other, turned into what the writer calls a marathon of driving, overeating and cranky children. Last year, the writer says, the youngest cried in the car from tiredness at rushing between houses.

Many families will recognize the squeeze. Readers sorting out a holiday schedule can compare notes with this list of six things families quietly argue about at Thanksgiving dinner, and anyone budgeting the meal can look at what Thanksgiving dinner costs by state in 2026. For a host who wants to keep the kitchen manageable, there is a comparison of ways to free up the oven. Families who must drive between homes can look at family luggage sets for holiday trips, and for families trying to protect their energy through a busy season, a post on holiday pace and everyday habits offers a way to think about it. A host stocking coffee for early arrivals might consult this single cup or full pot comparison.

Each Spouse Thinks the Other Gives In Too Easily

The hardest part, in the writer’s telling, is that each spouse believes the other bends too quickly to their own parents. The writer says a husband thinks the writer is too easily moved by a mother’s guilt trips, while the writer thinks the husband gives in just as easily to his parents. What starts as a talk about turkey, the letter says, ends with an argument over whose family comes first.

Because the letter is one person’s account, the grandparents’ and the husband’s own views are known only through the writer. The writer is also open about being tired: the holiday is supposed to be about gratitude, and the writer admits to dreading it, and sometimes fantasizes about staying home in pajamas, ordering pizza and watching the parade. One widely watched Thanksgiving morning event is the Macy’s Thanksgiving Day Parade, which Wikipedia says was first held in 1924 and runs for three hours in Manhattan.

A giant parade balloon being inflated on a city street
Rhododendrites – CC BY-SA 4.0/Wikimedia Commons

What Dear Annie Told the Couple

Lane’s reply begins with sympathy for the grandparents. It is understandable, she writes, that both sets want Thanksgiving with their grandchildren, and as they get older such gatherings become more precious. She also says it is not possible to make everyone happy, especially at the expense of the writer’s own family’s peace.

Her advice has three parts. First, the couple should sit down together and agree on a plan, whether that means alternating years, hosting everyone or starting a tradition of their own. Second, they should be loving but firm with the grandparents. Third, they should remind them that they are cherished even when the family is not at their table. The holiday, she writes, is about being thankful for family, “not keeping score over who gets the turkey.” Wikipedia’s entry on the Ann Landers tradition notes that Lane was introduced as the columnist known as Dear Annie.

Plans Families Use to Avoid a Double Holiday

The three options named in the column each have a food angle. Hosting everyone means one big kitchen and one long table. Alternating years means two sets of recipes taking turns. A new tradition could be a Friday meal or a brunch the day after, which spreads out the cooking and the driving, though that idea is not in the column. Whichever plan a household chooses, the letter’s central point stands: the grandparents’ wish to see the children is real, and so is the family’s need for a holiday that does not end in tears in the back seat.

As Wikipedia’s Thanksgiving entry lists it, the day is a national and cultural holiday, and the column’s advice suggests that making room for both families may matter more than any single dinner.

This article was produced with AI assistance and edited for accuracy against the sources linked above.

Author

More Posts You May love

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *