The turkey is not even in the oven yet, but the guest list is already the hardest part of the meal. For one hostess, the question is how many relatives of relatives will end up around the table on Thanksgiving, which falls on Nov. 26 this year.
She put the problem to the etiquette column Miss Manners, and the answer ran on Oct. 27, 2026, under the headline “Extra Guests at Thanksgiving Are Kinda the Point.” The reply leans on the Thanksgiving legend itself, and it is a useful reminder before a holiday full of full houses.

The Letter: A Second Year of Hosting
According to the column on Arcamax, the writer is hosting her husband’s family for Thanksgiving for the second year in a row. Last year, her brother-in-law and his wife brought four of the wife’s relatives: her parents, her brother and his daughter. The writer had met them only a few times.
She made room for them, she says, but would rather not have guests invite people she barely knows into her home on a holiday. She also notes that she puts a good deal of time and effort into the table and the meal. Her husband grew up with extra holiday guests, and her sister-in-law does not like to cook, which is why the sister-in-law did not host.
The Request: Let the Guest List Stay Closed
The writer wants to know how to tell her brother-in-law and his wife that they are welcome, but that the invitation does not stretch to the wife’s extended family. It is a reasonable worry for anyone who has priced a holiday meal. A report on Thanksgiving dinner costs by state shows how fast the grocery bill grows with every added chair.
The column is written by Judith Martin and, since 2013, shared with her children Nicholas and Jacobina, according to Wikipedia’s Miss Manners entry. Martin began the column in 1978, and it runs in hundreds of newspapers.
Guests carry some of the weight, too. Asking a host before bringing anyone along is the plain courtesy, and the simple etiquette tips for a perfect houseguest on Frenz Hub go through more of what a guest can do. On the cooking side, a comparison of air fryers and toaster ovens shows how some hosts free up oven space when the table grows. Hosts with overnight company can also look at a coffee maker matchup for holiday guests to handle the morning after.
The disagreement also fits a pattern. Another list of things families quietly argue about at Thanksgiving dinner shows that guest counts and kitchen work are common sources of tension. The Miss Manners letter has only one side of the story, the hostess’s own, so the brother-in-law’s view is not on record.
The Reply: Thanksgiving Is About Welcoming
Miss Manners starts with a question: does the writer know the Thanksgiving legend? She says the holiday is about inclusive hospitality. Had the writer objected that hosting so many people was too much work, the column says it would have been sympathetic and would have suggested sharing the load, beginning with the husband or by asking other relatives to host.
But Thanksgiving, the column concludes, is not the occasion to complain about sharing a meal with people the writer barely knows. The advice sorts the problem in two: the workload is fair to raise, and the extra guests are, in this reading, part of the point. A kitchen checklist for Thanksgiving dinner can help turn the work side into a manageable plan.

The Legend: A Meal With Ninety Guests
The legend Miss Manners points to has a head count. Plimoth Patuxet Museums’ Thanksgiving history page says the 1621 harvest celebration included the Pilgrim colonists and Massasoit, a Wampanoag leader, with about 90 of his men. It lasted three days, and the exact dates are unknown, though it took place sometime between Sept. 21 and Nov. 9, 1621.
Edward Winslow’s letter to a friend in England is the only surviving record. Four men sent hunting killed enough wild fowl to feed the group for almost a week, and the Wampanoag later brought five deer. According to Wikipedia’s Thanksgiving entry, four adult women cooked the feast. The colonists had lost about half their number the previous winter. The first Thanksgiving, in other words, was a meal with a very long guest list.
What Hosts Can Do Without Giving Up the Table
The column’s advice points to two routes: ask for help, starting at home, or ask other relatives to host. Beyond the column, a host can also decide in advance how many seats the kitchen can handle and say so early, before invitations multiply. Hospitality, after all, has long come with rules for both sides; Wikipedia’s hospitality entry notes that in ancient Greece, xenia obliged hosts to meet guests’ needs while guests were expected to follow a code of conduct.
The takeaway for hosts everywhere is practical: decide early what the kitchen, the budget and the seating can handle, and ask for help before resentment builds. The takeaway for guests is just as plain, which is to ask before bringing extra company and to arrive ready to pitch in.
For the hostess, the column’s answer was that the work can be shared and the table can stay open. Whether she agrees is up to her, and Thanksgiving is Nov. 26, with a few more days to plan.
This article was produced with AI assistance and edited for accuracy against the sources linked above.
Image: Famartin – CC BY-SA 4.0/Wikimedia Commons