The refrigerator door is the busiest real estate in the kitchen, and the bottles lined up on it often outlast the meals they were bought for. Mayonnaise, ketchup and mustard each carry a different expiration clock once the seal is cracked.
A Safeway shopping guide that cites USDA’s FoodKeeper puts the numbers this way: commercial mayonnaise keeps 2 months after opening, ketchup 6 months and mustard 1 year. The Safeway condiment guide lays out refrigerated-after-opening and pantry-from-purchase times side by side, and the figures show how little the three sauces have in common.

Mayonnaise: The 2-Month Jar
Mayonnaise has the shortest refrigerated clock of the headline trio. The Safeway guide lists commercial mayonnaise at 3 to 6 months in the pantry from purchase and 2 months once opened. It also quotes Hellmann’s, which says to use opened mayonnaise within 2 to 3 months, a figure the guide notes is not from the USDA FoodKeeper.
The Kansas State cupboard chart, which lists unopened shelf times at 70°F, puts unopened mayonnaise at 3 to 4 months and says to refrigerate after opening and check the package date. FoodSafety.gov describes the FoodKeeper as a tool built by USDA’s Food Safety and Inspection Service with Cornell University and the Food Marketing Institute to help food stay fresh and keep its quality longer. A feature on items to store in the refrigerator at all times shows where a jar like this fits.
The sauce has a long story behind a short shelf life. Wikipedia describes mayonnaise as an emulsion of oil, egg yolk and an acid such as vinegar or lemon juice, and says most accounts place its origin on Menorca. The same mayonnaise entry says Hellmann’s was mass-marketed in 1912 and trademarked in 1926 as Hellmann’s Blue Ribbon Mayonnaise. How condiments are sold and served still varies by country, as a roundup of food laws and rules in other countries shows.
Ketchup at 6 Months, Mustard at a Year
The Safeway guide lists ketchup at 6 months refrigerated after opening, after a year in the pantry unopened. Mustard runs longer, at 1 year after opening and 1 to 2 years from purchase.
Wikipedia’s ketchup entry explains part of why ketchup is so durable. In the early 1900s, it says, sugar and vinegar were increased to preserve ketchup without a chemical preservative, and Henry J. Heinz pursued that recipe, helping establish the sweet-and-sour tomato ketchup common today. The same entry traces the first known tomato ketchup recipe to 1812, from James Mease.
Those long clocks do not mean the bottle should sit indefinitely. Pushed to the back of a crowded shelf, a bottle can outlast several jars of newer purchases. A look at small kitchen ideas covers ways to keep the door tidy, a recent list of fridge and freezer checks before the big grocery run fits the same week of holiday shopping, and a feature on 1960s kitchens looks back at what sat on those shelves decades ago.

Soy Sauce, Barbecue Sauce and Dressing on the Same Shelf
The Safeway guide’s FoodKeeper figures cover more of the door. Soy sauce is listed at 3 years in the pantry and 1 month refrigerated after opening. Bottled barbecue sauce is 1 year in the pantry and 4 months after opening. Bottled commercial salad dressing is 10 to 12 months in the pantry and 1 to 3 months after opening.
Hot sauce is listed at 6 months in the pantry, and the guide gives no refrigerated figure for it. When a figure is missing, the bottle’s own label is the better guide.
Laid out in order, the opened clocks run from the shortest to the longest this way: soy sauce at 1 month, mayonnaise at 2 months, dressing at 1 to 3 months, barbecue sauce at 4 months, ketchup at 6 months, mustard at 1 year. A short strip of tape with the opening date on each bottle turns that list into something usable.
What the Room-Temperature Chart Says Instead
Kansas State’s chart gives a second set of numbers, listed at 70°F, and the gap shows why the door matters. Opened ketchup is listed at 1 month, with the note to refrigerate for longer storage. Prepared yellow mustard is listed at 6 to 8 months opened, unopened at 1 year, with a note that it may be refrigerated and should be stirred before using.
Read together, the two charts give ketchup 1 month on the shelf and 6 months in the cold, and mustard 6 to 8 months on the shelf and 1 year in the cold. That is the clock the headline describes, and it is why the refrigerated column is the one to follow.
Two charts built for two kinds of shelves will not match, and a home cook who reads both can take the shorter number as a reminder to use the bottle first.
A Thanksgiving Week Reset for the Door Shelves
Thanksgiving falls on Nov. 26, and the refrigerator door tends to fill with cranberry sauce, gravy and extra mayonnaise for the leftovers. Clearing out old bottles first makes room. The tape-and-marker habit is quick, and the figures from the Safeway guide are easy to remember: 2 months, 6 months and 1 year.
Mayonnaise gets the earliest deadline of the three, ketchup follows, and mustard waits longest. Whichever bottle has been open the longest should be the first one back on the table.
This article was produced with AI assistance and edited for accuracy against the sources linked above.
Image: Eric Fischer – CC BY 2.0/Wikimedia Commons