5 Canned Foods to Skip at the Store and in the Pantry, From Bulging Lids to Sharp Dents on the Seam

The holiday baking aisle fills up fast in November, and shoppers reach past pyramids of pumpkin, cranberry sauce and green beans to grab whatever is closest. At home, the back of the pantry often holds a few cans that have been there since last Thanksgiving.

Extension food-safety specialists at Clemson University, North Dakota State University, the University of Nebraska-Lincoln and Texas A&M say a few warning signs mean a can belongs in the trash, not the cart or the casserole. Below are the 5 kinds of cans they say to leave behind, whether they sit on a store shelf or a home pantry shelf, along with how long the good ones keep.

Rows of canned food on a pantry shelf
ProjectManhattan – CC BY-SA 3.0/Wikimedia Commons

1. Cans With Bulging or Swollen Lids

A lid that domes up instead of sitting flat is the clearest stop sign. The Clemson Home & Garden Information Center fact sheet on canned goods, updated in June 2024, says a bulging lid is a sign of spoilage and the can should be thrown out. Cans and jars on the shelf should be free of dents, cracks or bulging lids before they go in the cart.

The same goes for a can that has been sitting at home. If a lid that was flat at the store has puffed up in the pantry, Clemson’s advice is the same: discard it. A few minutes spent checking the shelves before the holiday cooking starts can save a scramble later, much like the fridge and freezer checks to make before the big grocery run.

2. Cans That Are Leaking

A sticky ring on the shelf or a damp label usually means a can has a leak. Clemson lists a leaking can alongside a bulging lid as a sign of spoilage to discard. NDSU Extension’s guide to storing canned and packaged food, last reviewed in June 2025, also says not to buy or use cans that are leaking or bulging.

The Texas A&M AgriLife Dinner Tonight guide to can safety sums it up for shoppers: pick items that are tightly sealed with no leaks. Stocking up on sale cans can be a smart move for the grocery budget, and it fits with other frugal living tips for a tight budget, as long as each can passes a quick look first.

3. Cans With Sharp Dents on the Seam

Not every dent is a deal-breaker. The Nebraska Extension food safety FAQ says a can with a small dent that is otherwise in good shape should be fine, but deeply dented cans should be thrown out. It defines a deep dent as one a finger can be laid into.

The seams are the weak spot. Nebraska Extension says a sharp dent on the top or side seam can damage the seam, and any can with a deep dent on any seam should be discarded. NDSU says the same, warning against cans with sharp dents, especially in the seam. That joint matters because, as the Wikipedia history of the tin can explains, a modern can is sealed with a double seam, where the rims of the wall and the lid are folded together to form a tight joint without solder. Bargain bins of dented cans deserve a careful look, the same way shoppers weigh other items not worth buying at the grocery store.

Display of canned meats stacked on store shelves
State Government Photographer – CC0/Wikimedia Commons

4. Cans Covered in Heavy Rust

A little surface rust is not the same as a rusted-through can. Nebraska Extension and Texas A&M both say to discard heavily rusted cans, while surface rust that rubs off with a finger or a paper towel is not serious, and those cans can be kept. If a can is opened and there is any rust inside, the food should not be eaten.

Clemson adds that rust can lead to leaks, which is why it tells shoppers to check dented cans and jars for leakage and rust before buying. At home, the storage spot matters. NDSU says canned goods should not be stored under the sink, above the stove or anywhere with high or low temperature extremes, and a dry cupboard is the better spot. The same goes for other pantry upkeep tricks shared in roundups of clever kitchen tricks for home cooks.

5. Cans That Spurt, Smell Off or Show Mold When Opened

Some problems only show up at the can opener. Clemson says to discard canned food if liquid spurts out when the can is opened, if there is an off odor, or if there is mold. It also says not to taste canned food that shows any signs of spoilage.

Once a good can is opened, the leftovers need a new home. NDSU says to move the food out of the can and into another covered container before refrigerating or freezing it. Clemson puts opened pickles and olives at 1 to 2 months in the refrigerator, and opened tomato sauce and canned fruit at 5 to 7 days. A batch of leftover cranberry sauce scooped into a lidded dish is a simple holiday example, much like the budget pantry foods that even the wealthy eat.

How Long the Good Cans Keep

For cans that pass every check, storage temperature decides how long they last. Clemson says the best range is between 50°F and 70°F. High-acid canned foods such as tomatoes and fruit keep 12 to 18 months, and low-acid canned foods such as meat and vegetables keep 2 to 5 years in a cool, dry pantry. NDSU gives similar ranges and notes that a “best if used by” date on a can marks peak quality, not safety.

A quick pantry sort before the holiday shopping trip, with the oldest cans moved to the front, keeps the cranberry sauce from turning into next year’s mystery can.

This article was produced with AI assistance and edited for accuracy against the sources linked above.

Image: Born to Barnacle – CC0/Wikimedia Commons

Author

More Posts You May love

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *