3 Ways Americans Once Ate Out That Are Rarely Seen Anymore: the Automat, the Drive-In Carhop and the Dime-Store Lunch Counter

Today, eating out often means tapping an app, pulling up to a speaker box or grabbing a tray at a counter with a number on it. For earlier generations, a meal away from home could mean dropping coins into a wall of little glass doors, waiting for a carhop to hook a tray onto the car window or spinning on a stool at the dime store.

Those 3 ways of dining out once defined American lunch and supper, and all 3 are rarely seen anymore. Here is how the automat, the drive-in carhop and the dime-store lunch counter worked, and what happened to them, according to the historical record.

Diners inside a Horn and Hardart automat in New York with walls of coin-operated food compartments
Bernard Gotfryd – Public domain/Wikimedia Commons

1. The Automat: Dinner Behind a Glass Door

The automat was a restaurant where food waited in small, coin-operated compartments. Customers looked through a glass window, dropped in their money, lifted the door and took out a plate. Behind the wall, workers kept the slots stocked from the kitchen. Meals were usually wrapped in waxed paper, according to the automat’s documented history, and the whole process took less time than waiting for a server at a sit-down restaurant.

In the United States, the name most tied to the idea is Horn & Hardart. According to Wikipedia’s history of the automat, the company opened the first American automat on June 12, 1902, at 818 Chestnut St. in Philadelphia. It expanded to New York City in 1912, and at one time there were forty Horn & Hardart automats in the city. The early machines took only nickels, which made the automat a symbol of a cheap, quick meal for office workers and shoppers.

The history of Horn & Hardart shows how big the brand became in Philadelphia and New York before fast food changed the market. Competition from burger chains, inflation and a perceived decline in food quality wore the automats down. Many New York locations were converted into Burger King restaurants, and the last Horn & Hardart automat closed in 1991.

For readers who remember feeding nickels into those slots, Frenz Hub’s list of foods from the ’60s that many boomers loved brings back plenty of the same era’s flavors. A look at things nearly every 1960s kitchen had shows what was going on back home at the same time.

2. The Drive-In Carhop: Supper on a Window Tray

Before the drive-through window, there was the drive-in. Customers parked in a lot, ordered from the car and ate right there, often with a tray clipped to a half-rolled-down window. The person who brought the food was the carhop.

According to Wikipedia’s entry on drive-ins, the first drive-in restaurant was Kirby’s Pig Stand, which opened in Dallas, Texas, in 1921. At drive-ins, carhops walk or roller-skate out to take orders and return with the food. The format became a fixture of American car culture, and a popular weekend outing for families and teenagers alike.

Drive-ins hit their peak in North America in the 1950s and 1960s. After that, drive-throughs took over, rising to prominence in the 1970s and 1980s, and the carhop became much harder to find. A few classics hang on. The largest drive-in still operating is The Varsity in Atlanta, a spot generations of Georgia families know well. The Varsity’s own website says Frank Gordy opened it in 1928 on a 70-by-120-foot lot with a white picket fence, and the restaurant still promotes its “World Famous Chili.”

Frenz Hub’s roundup of little rituals from the ’80s and ’90s that disappeared picks up where the carhop era left off.

Carhops serving food to customers in parked cars at an A and W drive-in restaurant
Royalbroil – CC BY-SA 3.0/Wikimedia Commons

3. The Dime-Store Lunch Counter: A Stool, a Sandwich and a Slice of Pie

The third format lived inside the five-and-dime. Stores like Woolworth’s built long counters with swivel stools where shoppers could sit down between errands for a sandwich, a bowl of soup and a cup of coffee. It was a sit-down meal without the formality, or the price, of a full restaurant.

According to Wikipedia’s history of the lunch counter, Woolworth’s opened its first luncheonette in New Albany, Indiana, around 1923. Typical foods were hot and cold sandwiches, along with soups, pie, ice cream, sodas, milkshakes, coffee and hot chocolate. Lunch counters were still being built into dime stores as late as the 1950s.

The lunch counter also holds a serious place in American history. In 1960, the Woolworth’s lunch counter in Greensboro, North Carolina, was the site of one of the first sit-ins of the civil rights movement’s campaign to integrate lunch counters in the South.

By the 1960s, the counters were losing customers to fast-food chains and convenience stores, and they gradually faded from department and dime stores. Frenz Hub’s list of forgotten household items from the past shows how many everyday fixtures of that era went the same way.

Why These 3 Formats Faded

The same forces show up in all three stories. Fast-food chains offered speed and low prices on a national scale, drive-through windows let customers skip parking altogether, and convenience stores put a sandwich within reach on almost every corner. Rising costs made it harder to keep staff behind a wall of food slots, out on the lot or at a long counter.

Some longtime restaurants hold on until the very end, and loyal crowds often turn out when they close. One recent example involved hundreds of people lining up at a Royal Oak restaurant open since 1957 before it served its last plate.

The automat, the carhop and the lunch counter are rare sights today, but the ideas behind them live on in vending walls, drive-through lanes and diner counters. For many older Americans, the memory of a nickel in a slot or a tray on a car window is still part of what eating out used to mean.

This article was produced with AI assistance and edited for accuracy against the sources linked above.

Image: Horn & Hardart/Lumitone Photography, New York – Public domain/Wikimedia Commons

Author

More Posts You May love

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *