Stools, a long counter and a short menu once sat inside many American dime stores. Woolworth’s opened its first luncheonette in New Albany, Indiana, around 1923 and expanded rapidly, according to Wikipedia’s entry on lunch counters, and the typical fare at such counters included grilled cheese, BLT sandwiches, pie and milkshakes.
The counters persisted into the 1950s. Starting in the 1960s, the same entry says, they lost popularity to fast food restaurants such as McDonald’s and convenience stores such as 7-Eleven.

How a Dime-Store Counter Worked
A lunch counter, as Wikipedia describes it, is a small restaurant similar to a diner. The customer sits on a stool on one side of the counter while the server works from the other side, where the kitchen or food preparation area sits. The name reflects the main meal, since the counters were primarily used for lunch.
The business logic was simple. The intent of a lunch counter inside a store was to profit from serving hungry shoppers and to attract people to the store so they might buy merchandise. Members of the retail staff who had taken lunch counter training would work the counter during the lunch rush, and the entry says counters were built into dime stores as late as the 1950s.
Woolworth’s was not alone. The entry says counters were often found in other dime stores such as Newberry’s, S. H. Kress, H. L. Green, W. T. Grant, McLellan’s and McCrory’s. Wikipedia’s Woolworth entry traces the idea to the success of the counters at the company’s first store in the United Kingdom, in Liverpool, a different starting point from the New Albany date above. It describes the counters as general gathering places, a precursor to the modern shopping mall food court.
Grilled Cheese and the Hot Sandwiches
Wikipedia lists the typical sandwiches as hot and cold, including ham and cheese, grilled cheese, BLT, patty melt and egg salad. The grilled cheese entry describes a hot cheese sandwich made by placing cheese between slices of bread and cooking it with butter or mayonnaise on a frying pan or griddle until the bread browns and the cheese melts. Despite the name, it says, the sandwich is rarely prepared through grilling.
The same entry says the cheese dream, an open-faced grilled cheese sandwich, became popular in the United States during the Great Depression. Nostalgia for plain, filling food like this runs through a roundup of foods from the 1960s that many boomers loved, and a list of 5 things found in nearly every American kitchen of the 1970s carries the memory forward a decade.
BLTs and Egg Salad
The BLT is named for the initials of its main ingredients, bacon, lettuce and tomato. Wikipedia’s BLT entry says there is little evidence of BLT recipes before 1900, though the ingredients themselves had existed for many years. It points to a club sandwich recipe in the 1903 Good Housekeeping Everyday Cook Book that included bacon, lettuce, tomato, mayonnaise and a slice of turkey.
Egg salad is the cold-sandwich companion on the list. According to the egg salad entry, a typical version is made of chopped hard-boiled eggs, mayonnaise, mustard and minced celery and onion, and a common use is as a filling for sandwiches. One of the earliest known printed recipes for egg salad sandwiches appeared in the 1896 edition of The Boston Cooking-School Cook Book by Fannie Farmer, per the same entry.

Soup, Pie, Sundaes and Milkshakes
The rest of the typical menu, per the lunch counter entry, was soups, pie, soda, coffee and hot chocolate. The sources describe a lineup of items rather than a fixed menu from a particular year or store, and they give no prices. Plain, inexpensive meals are the subject of a list of 15 “poor people foods” that even the wealthy eat.
Sitting at a counter for lunch is one of many everyday habits that faded, a theme in a list of 8 little rituals from the ’80s and ’90s that disappeared without much notice. Another look at 1960s home life appears in a list of 5 things nearly every 1960s living room had because of the television.
The lunch counter entry lists ice cream among the typical offerings, including sundaes, ice cream sodas and milkshakes. Each has its own history on Wikipedia. A sundae is a frozen dessert of ice cream topped with a sweet sauce or syrup, and the first recorded use of the word, spelled “Sunday,” came in an advertisement in Ithaca, New York, on April 5, 1892.
The ice cream soda is made by adding ice cream to a soft drink or to a mixture of flavored syrup and carbonated water. The traditional story credits Robert M. Green, who is said to have invented it in Philadelphia in 1874 during the Franklin Institute’s semicentennial celebration. A milkshake is made by blending milk, ice cream and flavorings into a thick, cold mixture, and the entry says milkshakes originated in the United States around the turn of the 20th century and gained wide popularity after electric blenders arrived.
Wikipedia’s soda fountain entry adds that a soda shop or luncheonette, common from the late 19th century until the mid-20th century, was often inside a drugstore, candy store or other business, where a soda jerk served carbonated beverages, ice cream and sometimes light meals.
Why the Counters Faded
Fast food and convenience stores took the lunch crowd, according to the lunch counter entry. The company itself, which began in 1879 with a store in Utica, New York, and found its footing in Lancaster, Pennsylvania, later that year, ended in 1997, per Wikipedia, with Foot Locker as its successor.
The Woolworth’s lunch counter in Greensboro, North Carolina, was also the site of one of the first lunch counter sit-ins of the civil rights movement in 1960, and part of that counter is now at the Smithsonian’s National Museum of American History. The former store is home to the International Civil Rights Center and Museum, and the Greensboro sit-ins entry covers that history in detail.
This article was produced with AI assistance and edited for accuracy against the sources linked above.
Image: jeffreyw – CC BY 2.0/Wikimedia Commons