13 Thanksgiving Sides Found Only in Certain Parts of the U.S., From Wild Rice Hotdish to Shrimp Mirlitons

Thanksgiving falls on Nov. 26, and the side dishes on the table depend heavily on the map. A list by Brian Boone for The Takeout, published Nov. 16, 2025, counted 13 sides found only in certain parts of the United States, running from wild rice hotdish in Minnesota to shrimp mirlitons in Louisiana.

The Takeout list is a year old, so the dishes here are described as long-running regional traditions rather than news. Each of the 13 appears below by region, with background from Wikipedia and a High Point University library guide to regional Thanksgiving dishes.

A dish of stuffing prepared for Thanksgiving dinner
Dorevabelfiore – CC BY-SA 4.0/Wikimedia Commons

The Northeast: Oysters, Grapes, Onions, Potatoes and Sauerkraut

Oyster stuffing, the first of the 13, belongs to New England and some Southern states, according to The Takeout. Wikipedia’s entry on stuffing confirms that oysters turn up in one traditional Thanksgiving version, and notes that the same dish goes by stuffing, filling or dressing depending on the cook.

Concord grape pie is the second, tied by The Takeout to upstate New York and parts of New England. Wikipedia’s page on grape pie links it to the Finger Lakes and the town of Naples, New York, and describes a laborious process of skinning the grapes, cooking the pulp and separating the seeds. It also says German immigrants brought the pie to the region.

Creamed onions, third, are pearl onions in a white sauce, listed for New England, parts of the Midwest and the South. They share the table with old-school favorites such as those in a roundup of foods from the ’60s that most boomers loved.

Potato filling is the fourth, a Pennsylvania Dutch dish. Wikipedia describes it as mashed potatoes combined with bread, served as a stuffing or baked on its own as a casserole, and says it has been served for centuries in parts of Pennsylvania such as Berks County. Casserole-style fillings like this one need refrigerator room before the holiday, and the fridge and freezer checks to make before the big grocery run cover that planning. Sauerkraut rounds out the group as the fifth, a Greater Baltimore side that The Takeout links to German immigrants.

The South: Giblet Gravy and Louisiana Mirlitons

Turkey giblet gravy with chopped hard-boiled eggs is the sixth dish, which The Takeout places in the South. A regional side like this one is the kind of family tradition collected in a list of 14 strange Thanksgiving traditions.

Shrimp mirlitons are the seventh. A mirliton is the Louisiana name for the chayote, a squash, and Wikipedia’s chayote entry says Creole and Cajun cooks regard it as a popular seasonal holiday dish, especially around Thanksgiving. The Takeout describes the version that mixes the squash with shrimp and seasonings. For households that keep the same dishes every year, five traits often shared by people who keep the exact same holiday traditions make a good companion read.

A pan of tater tot hotdish at a Minnesota gathering
Myotus – CC BY 4.0/Wikimedia Commons

The Midwest: Hotdish and Persimmon Pudding

Wild rice hotdish, the eighth side, is Minnesota’s contribution. According to Wikipedia, a hotdish is a casserole that usually combines a starch, a meat and a vegetable with canned soup. Local wild rice has become a popular starch alongside tater tots, and the page recalls two congressional entries from the annual Minnesota Congressional Hotdish Off: a chicken mushroom wild rice hotdish in 2011 and a winning turkey, sweet potato and wild rice dish in 2015.

Persimmon pudding, the ninth, is Indiana’s. Wikipedia’s entry on persimmon pudding says it uses the pulp of the wild American persimmon, calls it one of two iconic Indiana dishes alongside sugar cream pie, and notes that it was the state’s most searched Thanksgiving recipe in 2014. It is sold with ice cream each year at the Persimmon Festival in Mitchell, Indiana. Cooks juggling a casserole and a pudding can look to a comparison of countertop ovens that free up the main oven this Thanksgiving.

The West and Southwest: Sourdough, Mushrooms, Frog Eyes and Empanadas

Sourdough stuffing is the tenth, tied to San Francisco. Wikipedia’s sourdough page says French bakers brought sourdough techniques to Northern California during the Gold Rush and describes San Francisco sourdough as a white bread with a pronounced sourness. The Takeout lists sourdough stuffing as the dish that carries that tang to the Thanksgiving table.

Sautéed mushrooms are the eleventh, a side from Oregon and Washington, where The Takeout describes wild mushrooms cooked in butter with fresh herbs. The High Point guide also lists wild mushrooms such as chanterelles and morels among the West Coast’s gravies and stuffings.

Frog eye salad is the twelfth, a Utah favorite. Wikipedia’s entry on frog eye salad says it is built on acini di pepe pasta, whipped topping and egg yolks, often with mandarin oranges and pineapple and sometimes marshmallows. The name refers to the pasta resembling frog’s eyes, and the dish is associated with Utah and Idaho.

Pumpkin empanadas close the list as the thirteenth, from New Mexico and the Southwest: spiced pumpkin filling baked into half-moon pastries, according to The Takeout.

Taken together, the 13 show how local Thanksgiving menus can be. The Takeout list names a dish for each region, and the background pages add the details: German immigrants in the Northeast and Baltimore, Gold Rush bakers in California, wild rice in Minnesota, persimmons in Indiana and chayote in Louisiana. Each dish carries the history of the place where it is served.

For Nov. 26, that makes the side dishes a good place to ask relatives which recipes came from where. Some of the 13 may already be on the table, and a few may be new to a household that has never seen a frog eye salad or a pan of potato filling.

This article was produced with AI assistance and edited for accuracy against the sources linked above.

Image: KevinStuart23 – CC0/Wikimedia Commons

Author

  • Emma Flavia

    Emma Flavia is a lifestyle and entertainment writer who dives into the ways people live, think, and connect in a world shaped by trends and technology. She has written for high-profile platforms such as MSN and NewsBreak, covering mental wellness, relationships, digital culture, and the latest social phenomena with insight and flair. Passionate about the human experience, Emma also finds inspiration in nature walks, minimalist digital art, experimenting with color palettes, and documentaries that explore behavior and design.

More Posts You May love

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *