Somewhere in Utah, a bowl of pale, fluffy salad with tiny pasta sits right next to the turkey, and nobody at the table finds that strange. A few states away, in Louisiana, the side dish is mashed squash stuffed back into its shell with shrimp.
Thanksgiving menus change from region to region, and 13 dishes in particular are found mostly in their home territories. The list below draws on The Takeout’s roundup of regional sides, published Nov. 16, 2025, and adds notes from Lonely Planet (last updated November 2020), a High Point University library guide from 2023 and Food Network. These are older guides, so they are framed here as cultural background rather than this year’s news.

Oyster Stuffing in New England and Parts of the South
The Takeout’s list begins with bread-based stuffing made with oysters, a tradition it traces to at least the 1600s. Lonely Planet places it along the Gulf coast and in New England. Anyone budgeting for the whole menu can compare Thanksgiving dinner costs by state first. Home cooks planning a crowded holiday can also look at how to free up the oven on Thanksgiving before piling on extra dishes.
Wild Rice Hotdish in Minnesota
In Minnesota, the casserole is a one-pot hotdish of wild rice, meat, vegetables and soup, often served with the turkey. Lonely Planet also notes that wild rice is especially popular in the northern Midwest, near the Canadian border. Guests bringing a dish to a relative’s table can brush up on simple etiquette tips for being the perfect houseguest.
Concord Grape Pie in Upstate New York
Concord grape pie belongs to upstate New York and parts of New England. The Takeout describes a simple, inexpensive pie made from local grapes that grew popular during the Depression, and Lonely Planet lists it as New York State’s contribution.
Giblet Gravy With Eggs in the South
Southern tables often serve a thick gravy built on turkey drippings and giblets, with sliced hard-boiled eggs mixed in. Lonely Planet confirms the sliced or crumbled egg detail for the Southern United States.
Sourdough Stuffing in San Francisco
In California, especially San Francisco, stuffing is made with tangy sourdough, a style The Takeout links to the Gold Rush era. Lonely Planet adds that West Coast stuffing sometimes includes apples as well.
Sauteed Wild Mushrooms in the Pacific Northwest
In Oregon and Washington, wild mushrooms such as morels and chanterelles are sauteed in butter with fresh herbs. The High Point University library guide likewise names wild mushrooms for the West Coast and Pacific Northwest, alongside Dungeness crab, salmon and oysters.
Sauerkraut Near Baltimore
Around Baltimore, a bowl of sauerkraut sits on the Thanksgiving table, a custom The Takeout connects to German immigrant influence. Travelers heading to relatives there this season can look at carry-on suitcases for Thanksgiving trips.

Frog Eye Salad in Utah
Frog eye salad is a sweet, creamy mix of pudding, canned fruit, whipped topping, marshmallows, coconut and tiny pasta, found in Utah and in nearby Latter-day Saint communities in Nevada and Colorado, according to The Takeout. In plain terms, it sits somewhere between a salad and a dessert, which is part of why it shows up beside the turkey at holiday tables. Lonely Planet separately names a lime-based gelatin salad for Utah, usually with cottage cheese and pineapple.
Creamed Onions in New England
Creamed onions are pearl onions in a rich, white-sauce style topping, sometimes baked. The Takeout places them in New England, parts of the Midwest and the South, and Lonely Planet files them under New England, so the dish turns up in several parts of the country. A hosting guide such as the things families quietly argue about at Thanksgiving dinner shows how much side dishes can matter to a table.
Persimmon Pudding in Indiana
In Indiana, the dessert is a spongy, eggy persimmon pudding spiced with nutmeg, vanilla and cinnamon. Lonely Planet pairs it with Indiana’s sugar cream pie, and notes that California has its own persimmon pudding made with the hachiya persimmon, brought by Japanese immigrants.
Pumpkin Empanadas in New Mexico
New Mexico and the wider Southwest serve half-moon pastries filled with spiced pumpkin and piloncillo as a snack or dessert. Lonely Planet adds red chile gravy for New Mexico, Food Network’s state-by-state list names biscochitos, and the High Point guide lists tamales, green chili cornbread and posole for the Southwest.
Shrimp Mirlitons in Louisiana
Shrimp mirlitons are mashed mirliton squash mixed with shrimp, vegetables and Cajun or Creole seasonings, often baked in the squash shells. The mirliton is the vegetable Wikipedia describes as chayote, and Food Network also names shrimp-stuffed mirliton for Louisiana.
Potato Filling in Pennsylvania Dutch Country
Pennsylvania Dutch and Amish communities in the Northeast combine mashed potatoes and bread-based stuffing in one dish called potato filling, according to The Takeout. It is the last of the 13, and perhaps the most comforting. Combining two sides in one dish also means one less pan on a crowded holiday stove.
These regional dishes have a few things in common: local ingredients, immigrant roots and family habits that outlast trends. Local ingredients shape many of them, from oysters on the coast and wild rice in the north to grapes in upstate New York and persimmons in Indiana. Thanksgiving falls on the fourth Thursday of November, which is Nov. 26 in 2026, according to Wikipedia’s Thanksgiving entry, which leaves a week to try a dish from somewhere else.
This article was produced with AI assistance and edited for accuracy against the sources linked above.
Image: Kristen Rapp – CC BY 2.0/Wikimedia Commons