Every refrigerator cleanout seems to turn up the same casualties: a bag of lettuce gone slimy, strawberries fuzzy at the bottom of the carton, a head of broccoli turning yellow. Often the food was not old so much as stored in the wrong spot, packed beside the apples in whichever drawer had room.
Appliance makers say the two crisper drawers are meant to be used differently. Leafy greens, berries and broccoli belong in the high-humidity drawer, while apples, pears and stone fruit go in the low-humidity one, and the reason comes down to moisture and a ripening gas called ethylene.

How the Two Drawers Actually Work
A crisper drawer is a compartment designed to keep produce fresh longer by holding more humidity than the rest of the refrigerator. According to the Wikipedia entry on the crisper drawer, closing the vent cuts off airflow and raises humidity, while opening it lets air circulate and lowers humidity. Drawers with no control at all default to high humidity.
Maytag explains that the moisture comes from the food itself, and the slider only sets how fast that moisture escapes. In Maytag’s crisper drawer guide, closed vents mean high humidity and open vents mean low humidity, though settings vary by model and the owner’s manual has the final word. Maytag also suggests filling a crisper only about two-thirds full so air can move around the produce.
Refrigerators with two drawers give a household one of each. Anyone already sorting the shelves, perhaps working from a list of essential items to keep in the refrigerator, can set one drawer high and one low and sort produce accordingly.
Leafy Greens and Lettuce Go in the High-Humidity Drawer
Whirlpool’s guidance is plain on this point. In its guide to organizing a refrigerator, Whirlpool says the high-humidity drawer is for thin-skinned produce such as leafy greens, and that lettuce keeps well there too. These foods lose water quickly, and a closed vent keeps that moisture in the drawer instead of letting the leaves go limp.
The Iowa State University Extension AnswerLine, in a post published September 22, 2016, describes the high-humidity drawer as the more tightly sealed one, meant for greens and other produce that loses moisture quickly. Fresh herbs and cucumbers also appear on Maytag’s high-humidity list. Gardeners bringing in the last of the season’s lettuce and kale from setups like these elevated garden beds for fall greens can send that harvest straight to the closed-vent drawer.
Berries and Broccoli Join Them
Berries and broccoli round out the high-humidity side. Whirlpool names broccoli and strawberries among the thin-skinned, ethylene-sensitive items for that drawer. Housewares maker OXO’s fridge organizing guide places leafy greens, berries and asparagus there as well, because they wilt easily.
OXO adds one habit that matters for berries in particular: do not wash produce until it is about to be eaten, because moisture encourages bacteria and speeds spoilage. Whirlpool says the same added moisture can speed ripening. Rinsing a whole carton of strawberries on grocery day and putting them away wet tends to shorten their life in the drawer.

Apples, Pears and Stone Fruit Go in the Low-Humidity Drawer
The other drawer belongs to the fruit that gives off ethylene. Whirlpool lists stone fruit, pears and apples as ethylene emitters for the low-humidity drawer. Maytag’s low-humidity list includes apples, pears, avocados, melons, mushrooms and pitted fruits.
The Iowa State AnswerLine post describes the low-humidity drawer as the one more open to airflow, best for fruits that tend to rot. Letting some of the gas escape helps everything in that drawer last longer. As a broad rule, the extension says, fruits generally prefer low humidity and vegetables generally prefer high humidity.
Apples do not have to go into the drawer right away. According to Whirlpool’s list of foods that should not be refrigerated, apples can sit on the counter for a week or two before moving to the fridge to stay fresh longer. Shoppers trimming waste from the weekly haul, along with skipping some of the items not worth buying at the grocery store, often find that simply storing fruit in the right place stretches the budget.
Why Ethylene Decides the Split
Ethylene is a natural gas some fruits release as they ripen. OXO says apples, pears and bananas give it off, and that it can make many vegetables wilt and spoil. Whirlpool says emitters can make ethylene-sensitive produce ripen faster, which is why the two groups should be kept apart.
That is the whole logic of the two-drawer split. The open vent on the low-humidity side lets the gas drift out rather than building up, and the closed high-humidity side keeps greens and berries away from it. Maytag specifically advises keeping ethylene-sensitive fruits such as strawberries away from the emitters. Before the holiday cooking rush, a quick sort fits naturally into the fridge and freezer checks to make before the big grocery run, along with other clever kitchen tricks for home cooks.
What Stays Out of Both Drawers
Some produce does not belong in the refrigerator at all. Whirlpool lists whole tomatoes, bananas, potatoes, onions and avocados among foods to keep out of the fridge, noting that refrigerator moisture can make onions soft and moldy and potatoes gritty and sweet. Iowa State agrees on tomatoes, bananas, potatoes, sweet potatoes, onions and dry garlic, saying cool, dry storage suits them better.
For the drawers that do get used, the appliance makers suggest a few small habits: line the bottom with paper towels for easy cleanup, avoid overcrowding, and keep the door closed as much as possible. With greens, berries and broccoli on one side and apples, pears and stone fruit on the other, the weekly cleanout should turn up far fewer surprises.
This article was produced with AI assistance and edited for accuracy against the sources linked above.