The lights flicker, the furnace goes quiet and the kitchen falls silent except for the drip of melting ice in the freezer. Hours later, when the power comes back, the same question lands in every household: what in the refrigerator can still be eaten, and what has to go in the trash?
The federal government’s food-safety site has a plain answer. FoodSafety.gov’s power outage chart sorts refrigerated foods into keep and discard columns, using one main cutoff: food held at 40°F or above for more than 2 hours. Some staples, like hard cheese, butter and peanut butter, come through fine. Others, like milk and gravy, do not.

The Clock Starts When the Power Goes Out
Before anything gets sorted, timing matters. According to FoodSafety.gov, a refrigerator keeps food safe for up to 4 hours during an outage. A full freezer holds its temperature for about 48 hours, and a half-full freezer for about 24 hours, as long as the door stays closed.
The U.S. Food and Drug Administration gives the same numbers in its guidance on food during outages and floods, and adds a practical tip: keep appliance thermometers in both compartments. The refrigerator should read 40°F or below and the freezer 0°F or below. Without a thermometer, nobody in the house can say for sure how warm things got.
Ready.gov, the federal preparedness site run by FEMA, repeats the most important habit on its emergency food page: keep the refrigerator and freezer doors shut as much as possible. Every peek lets cold air escape.
Those numbers are worth reviewing now, before winter storms arrive. One home guide lays out things never to do when home alone in a winter power outage, and Frenz Hub has advice on building an emergency fund that can cover replacing a fridge full of groceries.
What Can Stay: Hard Cheese, Butter and Peanut Butter
The keep column on FoodSafety.gov’s chart is longer than many people expect. After more than 2 hours at 40°F or above, these refrigerated items can stay:
Hard cheeses. Cheddar, Swiss and Parmesan are listed as keepers, along with processed cheeses.
Butter and margarine. Both stay on the keep list.
Peanut butter, jelly and condiments. Peanut butter and jelly can be kept, as can mustard, ketchup, pickles and olives.
Breads and baked goods. Bread, cakes, cookies and fruit pies are on the keep side of the chart.
That means a sandwich of bread, peanut butter and jelly, with a wedge of Cheddar on the side, is still on the menu after an evening without power. Many families who keep peanut butter in the fridge out of habit may find that it is one of the easiest things to save. For a broader look at what tends to live on refrigerator shelves, Frenz Hub’s roundup of items to keep in the refrigerator at all times is a useful companion to the federal chart.

What Has to Go: Milk, Gravy and Leftovers
The discard column is where most of the fridge ends up. FoodSafety.gov says these items should be thrown out once they have spent more than 2 hours at 40°F or above:
Meat, poultry and seafood. Raw or cooked, they go.
Gravy, lunchmeats and hot dogs. All three are on the discard list.
Soft and shredded cheeses. Brie, cottage cheese and mozzarella are listed as discards, as are shredded and low-fat cheeses. That is a key difference from the hard cheeses that can stay.
Milk, cream and yogurt. Dairy that pours or spoons goes.
Cooked pasta, rice and potatoes. Leftover sides are on the discard side.
Casseroles, soups and stews. Prepared dishes are also out.
The chart puts the rule in four plain words: “When in Doubt, Throw it Out!” The FDA adds that appearance and smell cannot be relied on to judge whether food is still safe. A checklist of fridge and freezer checks before the big grocery run covers how to keep a fridge organized so the discard pile is easier to sort.
One group of condiments plays by a different rule. According to FoodSafety.gov, opened mayonnaise, tartar sauce and horseradish only need to be thrown out if they have been above 50°F for more than 8 hours. That is a looser limit than the 40°F and 2-hour cutoff that covers most of the refrigerator.
The chart’s condition is specific, so it pays to know roughly how warm the fridge got. A thermometer reading taken when the power comes back is the simplest way to check.
The Freezer Has Its Own Rules
Frozen food usually fares better. The FDA says food from the freezer can be refrozen or cooked if it still contains ice crystals or reads 40°F or below. A full freezer gives a household roughly 2 days of cushion, which is why some families pack empty space with frozen water jugs before storm season. Frenz Hub’s guide to freezing fresh green beans is a reminder that a well-stocked freezer does double duty.
When an outage looks like it will run longer than 4 hours, the FDA suggests moving food into coolers with ice or frozen gel packs. Ready.gov notes that dry ice can keep a freezer cold for days, but it should be handled with thick, dry gloves and kept from touching food directly.
A Pantry That Doesn’t Need the Fridge
The other half of outage planning is the cupboard. The American Red Cross recommends a survival kit with non-perishable, easy-to-prepare food, and Ready.gov suggests canned meats, fruits and vegetables, dry cereal, peanut butter, dried fruit and shelf-stable milk, along with a manual can opener.
Put together, the federal advice is simple: keep the doors closed, watch the clock, check the thermometer, and use the keep-and-discard chart before anything goes back on the table.
This article was produced with AI assistance and edited for accuracy against the sources linked above.
Image: Bretwa – CC0/Wikimedia Commons