Starbucks’ $9 Braised Short Rib Grilled Cheese Draws a TikTok Complaint From @liftwithlipp After the Meat Covered About a Quarter of One Slice

A customer who posts on TikTok as @liftwithlipp showed her Starbucks Braised Short Rib Grilled Cheese taken apart on a napkin, with a flake of meat covering only about a quarter of one slice of bread. The sandwich costs roughly $9 after tax in many states, according to The Mary Sue, which reported on the video November 12.

The customer, identified by the outlet as Ashley, wrote on screen that she was already at her limit and that Starbucks “thinks this qualifies as a braised short rib grilled cheese.” Her caption asked the company, “Where is the rest of the short rib?” Not everyone who has bought the sandwich had the same experience, and a food reviewer who tried it on launch day came away happy.

A grilled cheese sandwich cut in half and stacked, showing melted yellow cheese between golden toasted slices of bread
Willis Lam – CC BY-SA 2.0/Wikimedia Commons

What the Video Shows

The video displays the sandwich opened up on one of the company’s napkins. According to The Mary Sue, the meat covers about a quarter of one slice of bread. BroBible, which wrote about the video on November 11, said the post had 488,400 views at the time. Those figures change, and the number is the outlet’s count from that date.

BroBible said it emailed Starbucks for comment and that its article reports no reply. The photograph in this article shows a generic grilled cheese sandwich and is not an image of the Starbucks product or the customer’s order.

The reaction has gone beyond one video. The Mary Sue, citing The Takeout, said X and Reddit users have posted sandwiches that looked light on meat, and some questioned whether the sandwich was worth about $9. One X user asked whether it was a short rib sandwich or a grilled cheese with meat seasoning. The price-versus-portion question echoes a list of 14 outrageously expensive products Americans are overpaying for.

What Starbucks Says the Sandwich Is

Starbucks introduced the sandwich with its holiday menu, which arrived November 5. The Mary Sue quotes the company’s holiday food announcement as calling it a classic grilled cheese “elevated with braised short rib, savory caramelized onion jam and a hint of Dijon.”

The sandwich sits among the seasonal food items that appear alongside the holiday drinks and cups each year. Wikipedia’s Starbucks entry says the chain was founded on March 30, 1971, at Seattle’s Pike Place Market, and that it releases holiday merchandise, including festive paper cups, from November to January.

Whether a meal is worth its price is a recurring question, and a list of 22 red flags that scream run when dining at a restaurant covers the warning signs diners watch for. Anyone who drinks coffee at home might browse 15 creative coffee bar ideas instead.

Price and portion drive a lot of fast-food debates, and a list of 5 purchases that should never be made with a debit card and a guide to 6 things never to do with a gift card during the holiday season both touch on how people pay for small purchases and gifts at this time of year.

A Starbucks Coffee storefront with green awnings and umbrellas over outdoor tables on a city street in Long Beach, California
Brad.K – CC BY 2.0/Wikimedia Commons

A Different Verdict From Tasting Table

The complaint is one side of the picture. Tasting Table published a review on November 9 in which the writer found the sandwich worth the cost and a standout among the new holiday items. The review described it as an upscale version of the classic sourdough grilled cheese, with braised short rib, caramelized onion jam, Dijon mustard and melted Cheddar, Parmesan and mozzarella.

The reviewer noted the bread looked hard and overly toasted at first and was somewhat firm, but said the flavors balanced it out. The Mary Sue reports that the Tasting Table writer paid $8.25 on launch day, which is a different price from the roughly $9 after tax it cites for many states.

Facebook comments quoted in the review were split as well. One Facebook fan called the sandwich “so dang good” and said two should have been bought, while another described it as soggy and greasy and called the experience “probably a fluke.” Those are individual comments, not a measure of how most customers feel.

Why Portions Can Vary

The Mary Sue notes that reactions under the video were mixed, with some commenters saying their own sandwiches looked much fuller, which suggests the amount of meat may vary from one order to the next. Others asked whether the sandwiches arrive prepackaged and defended baristas.

According to the outlet, citing a Tasting Table explainer, Starbucks sandwiches are prepared off-site by catering companies or manufacturers and shipped to stores, usually frozen, and employees warm them in high-speed ovens. That would suggest the amount of short rib is set at the production stage and not by the person behind the counter, though Starbucks has not commented on this sandwich in the reports reviewed.

A Short History of the Grilled Cheese

The sandwich at the center of the debate has a simple ancestor. Wikipedia’s grilled cheese entry defines it as a hot cheese sandwich with cheese placed between slices of bread and cooked until the bread browns and the cheese melts, and says it is rarely grilled in practice. It is typically cooked in a frying pan, on a griddle or in a pie iron, with butter or mayonnaise spread on the outside of the bread.

The entry adds that Cheddar and American cheese are the most widely used and that the open-faced cheese dream became popular during the Great Depression.

A fair summary of the dispute is short. One customer posted a video showing a flake of meat across about a quarter of one slice, and The Mary Sue and BroBible reported it. A Tasting Table reviewer called the same sandwich worth the money. The truth for any particular order may sit somewhere in between, since commenters and The Mary Sue both note that the amount of meat can differ from one sandwich to the next.

This article was produced with AI assistance and edited for accuracy against the sources linked above.

Image: Senator2029 – CC BY-SA 3.0/Wikimedia Commons

Author

More Posts You May love

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *